Jul 28, 2015

AFL

Archeologists discover forgotten ‘incorrect disposal’ rule

61 Comments

Archaeologists from the University of Melbourne have discovered a long forgotten Australian football rule known as ‘incorrect disposal’ while excavating a site in suburban Melbourne.

“It’s an extraordinary find,” said the team leader Dr Erin Fitzgerald.

“We’d heard rumours of such a rule existing but its exact wording was lost to us.”

The rule, written in an ancient text that is months, if not years old states:

When the football is in play, a Free Kick shall be awarded against a Player who hands the football to another Player or throws the football.

Former AFL umpire Ray McMartin said there had always been apocryphal stories about umpires paying free kicks for breaches of the rule in the distant past.

“I’ve never seen it paid myself but old Jack Thompson said he once saw it paid against University.”

“I always had my doubts though, I mean if this was a rule they’d be paying it every few minutes in the modern game.”

AFL umpires chief Wayne Campbell said the rule was technically still on the books but the league had no plans of enforcing it.

“We’re not that interested in old rules unless it’s tinkering with them.”

“The league is focused on introducing silly new rules that make umpires’ jobs harder and confuse fans.”

COMMENTS

Pugs22

Jul 28, 2015

GOLD

Billious

Jul 28, 2015

If they keep digging they might uncover Demetrio's sense of fairness and humour.  Rumour is they disappeared around the same time.

Kurt Mason

Jul 28, 2015

Trent Blight Chris Hayes

Andrew Buckis

Jul 28, 2015

Dane Balodis

Trent Blight

Jul 28, 2015

Not a baddie!!!!

Brendan McMahon

Jul 28, 2015

Steve Gosden we have been talking about this for years

Olivia D'Arrigo

Jul 28, 2015

Jeremy Thomas

Ben Neumann

Jul 28, 2015

Throwing and incorrect disposal are two different rules. Incorrect disposal requires prior opportunity, a throw doesnt. It's not that hard to understand....

Ryno Neil

Jul 28, 2015

Objectively you just ask "how did he get rid of it?".
This "knocked out in the tackle" is BS There is no reward for the tackler

Peter Jaeger

Jul 28, 2015

Sharon Richards good for a laugh

Noni Primrose

Jul 28, 2015

I knew it wasnt just me!

Megan Townsend

Jul 28, 2015

So bloody annoying

Mitch Burgess

Jul 28, 2015

Aaron Ballantyne Aaron Dimasi

Jeremy Thomas

Jul 28, 2015

Hahaha gold. Tim McInnes

Mitchell Powell

Jul 28, 2015

Agreed. Happens all the bloody time from local footy to AFL

Dan Walden

Jul 28, 2015

Darren McCall Ben Scambler

Andrew Taylor

Jul 28, 2015

Andrew O'Leary

Bradley McLeod

Jul 28, 2015

Joe Bland

Jean-Paul Stannus

Jul 28, 2015

When excavating this site... BEWARE the curse of Demetriou!!! BEWARE!!!!!

Joe Bland

Jul 28, 2015

Finally someone is talking about this... Everyone is complaining about congestion and stoppages I reckon if they started paying this when they should there would be less stoppages and it would be more free flowing

Harry Kent

Jul 28, 2015

spot on Mitch Courtney

Sam Bowen

Jul 28, 2015

Travis Stribley

James Briffa

Jul 28, 2015

Peter Briffa

Bruce Bell

Jul 28, 2015

About bloody time too

Dane Balodis

Jul 28, 2015

Thank GOD someone dug it up!

Erin Strong

Jul 28, 2015

Hunter J. Thompson

Joel Cuming

Jul 28, 2015

Strongly disagree, the player who gets the ball should be the number one priority. If that player has had prior opportunity (this is the key) then yes, they should dispose of it correctly. But if they just pick the ball up, get tackled straight sway and the ball is knocked out then it is play on (which is what the rule states by the way).

Jordan Scardetta

Jul 28, 2015

gotta have prior opportunity to dispose of it, because the alternative is a bunch of dudes too afraid to grab the footy, have it knocked out of their hands and get a free against for incorrect disposal. Difference between knocked out in the tackle and a throw.

Joel Cuming

Jul 28, 2015

Sadly, most of the football public and media/commentators do not understand this.

Ben Neumann

Jul 28, 2015

Nor do they seem to want to :/

Ryno Neil

Jul 28, 2015

Yeah I agree. Don't want blokes holding back or the other option is knock or soccer on. I think if it's an instant tackle fair enough, otherwise "knocked out in the tackle" is incorrect disposal.

Dodgi Robi Cvitti

Jul 28, 2015

Davidos Anthony Limoli

Davidos Anthony Limoli

Jul 28, 2015

Interpretation for the tip

Dean Cherry

Jul 28, 2015

Matt Cherry

Jordan Scardetta

Jul 28, 2015

yeah agree, prior opportunity is key. If we can get that right it'll go a long way.

Luke Trewartha

Jul 28, 2015

Ben Trewartha

Brad Martin

Jul 28, 2015

Dan Wilson

Nick Burgess

Jul 28, 2015

While they're at it, see if they can find 'kicking in danger' also. Hasn't been seen in a decade now, dangerously close to extinction.

Gary Coutts

Jul 28, 2015

Danny Smith

Rick Healy

Jul 28, 2015

But will they take notice

Bruce Bell

Jul 28, 2015

Mate it shits me to tears every bloody game I watch - dispose of the bloody ball

Rick Healy

Jul 28, 2015

Fkn oath...y they overthink the game is beyond me

Bruce Bell

Jul 28, 2015

u should see what they are doing at Junior level mate - we will have a whole generation of kids that can't defend as all the modified rules designed to promote 'skills' allow the ball carrier to do as he pleases!

Josh Barnes

Jul 28, 2015

Daniel Barnes

Rick Healy

Jul 28, 2015

I know went 2 watch a mate who coaches juniors last year....he no coach this year....can't stand it

Mitch Courtney

Jul 28, 2015

Truer words have never been written

Joel Cuming

Jul 28, 2015

The problem is that it's rare these days that players do have prior opportunity because there is so much congestion around the packs.

Christopher James Ryan

Jul 28, 2015

Remember when the look away over the head handball was a throw. See that not get paid every week too

Ben Turner

Jul 28, 2015

Marc Ohlmüs

Peter Moore

Jul 28, 2015

Kyle Halbert Rebecca Williams this is what I was talking about sunday! Haha

Frank Nac

Jul 28, 2015

Jamie Woolway

glamjunkie77

Jul 28, 2015

TitusOReily pity the picture you used was a trip or "legged"

Mike Teakle

Jul 28, 2015

Scoot Umpire

Tom Emery

Jul 28, 2015

Quentin Mitchell, exactly what we were saying the other night.

Tom Emery

Jul 28, 2015

Blokes can clean drop the ball in a tackle now and not get pinged.

Michael Ackers

Jul 28, 2015

Evan Young

Scoot Umpire

Jul 28, 2015

Its a crowd fave in the Barossa Mike Teakle

Mike Teakle

Jul 28, 2015

I thought you'd get a chuckle out of this

Scoot Umpire

Jul 28, 2015

Lovr titus hate the AFL senior panel

Moses Williams

Jul 28, 2015

Jonny Aston Kevin J Currell

Joanne Everett

Jul 29, 2015

Laugh! We (the fans) once did! Now nobody has a clue!