Apr 29, 2014

AFL

The AFL cannot be too hysterical about congestion

9 Comments

A lot has been written and said recently about how congestion and low scoring are ruining the game.

Personally, I’m in full agreement.

We cannot sit back and be calm about this. This unprecedented emergency requires two things, hysterical commentary and ill-thought out rule tinkering.

Despite its massive popularity and record revenue, AFL footy is always on the brink of collapse.

Remember how the slide tackle almost destroyed the game? Or what about when flooding almost ended our great sport forever?

I think the biggest danger we’ve had in recent years, is when the Hawks rushed several behinds in the 2008 Grand Final.

Luckily, the game was saved with a rule change. If the AFL hadn't reacted so quickly the 2009 season would have never happened.

Of course, many of the people who are now calling for rule changes to stop congestion, are the same people who say the AFL changes the rules too often.

Many of them also like to say the game is now too soft and over officiated.

I have no problem with this. Hysteria does not require a cogent argument. It mainly calls for lots of panic, shouting and where possible, blaming groups or individuals.

It seems sensible to me, to blame changes to the interchange rules for the current low scoring and then call for further rule changes to fix the unintended consequences of that rule change.

New rules set in train a wonderful series of events and outcomes that will enable us to complain about something else next season.

Of course, it would be simpler to acknowledge that the addition of two extra teams recently and the expansion of the competition over the last 20 years has diluted the talent pool and resulted in many teams adopting a defensive posture to cover for a lack of skilled players.

Unfortunately, that can’t be fixed with a rule change.

So tonight, when you’re lying in bed worrying about the imminent collapse of the AFL and the immediate takeover of Australian sport by soccer football, remember, this will all be fixed by some wonderful rule tinkering.

COMMENTS

Aaron Grogs

Jul 14, 2015

yes the hawks behinds rule change that never gets used anyway

Nathan-Super Coach-Thompson

Jul 14, 2015

We should be looking at player zones. A little bit like Auskick or even netball. Hey maybe the players could have bibs with letters on them so spectators will know what zone they belong in. FF (full forward), CHF (CENTRE half forward) FFS (umpires) ;-)

Dave Thomas

Jul 14, 2015

the games about as soft as netball now may as well have the bibs to

Jim Woodcock

Jul 14, 2015

If I remember correctly, they dealt with the rushed behinds problem by randomly awarding free kicks to the opposition after some rushed behinds in early 2009, and then quietly forgetting all about it.

Geoff Schaefer

Jul 14, 2015

I blame Shane Watson for much of the congestion in the game these days. Mind you, I blamed Watto when the cat took a dump on my toast this morning...

Matthew McClure

Jul 14, 2015

Jonathon Woolfrey

Matt Landy

Jul 14, 2015

It was the worse weekend of weather we had all year so that had a big impact which has not been mentioned at all. But I think alot of the screaming for rule changes is due to the enormous amount of coverage of the sport. It's way over the top. Goons need to talk or write about something to justify their six figure wages

Jonathon Woolfrey

Jul 14, 2015

Haha gold. And spot on.

Paul Lepore

Jul 14, 2015

Ryan Skurray on this mornings discussion about the AFL rules haha