Aug 12, 2024

AFL

The Monday Knee Jerk Reaction: Round Twenty Two

34 Comments

Footy is a passion, not some cold hearted, spread sheet dominated rational exercise.

On a Monday, you want irrational reaction. You want emotion to trump reason.

What you really want is idiotic hysteria.

You've come to the right place.

Friday

Sydney (89) v Collingwood (86)

First off, my apologies for not getting the column out last week. After a flight, my leg swelled up, which I’m informed is not good.

“It’s good luck right?” I ask the doctor.

“It’s very dangerous and further evidence that your diet of chicken nuggets, beer and Viennetta will kill you.”

To add to that, I had to also move house last week.

It made things a little tricky. The good news is I’m fine, but it’s back to flying privately for me.

Sydney, in an exciting new tactic, turned up this week.

And they did it in the best way possible, a comeback win over Collingwood, with Craig McRae complaining about the umpires favouring the home side.

I personally thought it was more a case of letting the Swans kick the last five goals of the game that was the problem.

McRae complaining about umpires favouring the home side is like George Calombaris complaining his pay packet was short this week. 

The Pies get 14 games at the MCG this season.

They only play away from the MCG nine times.

Three of those away games were at Marvel, and two of those were Collingwood home games, the other was against North Melbourne.

That means they only left Victoria six times, and one of those was for Gather Round, where they played Hawthorn.

You could be a Collingwood player and by the end of the season, you’re still a bronze Frequent Flyer.

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

Saturday

Brisbane (64) v Greater Western Sydney (82)

Now this was interesting.

Brisbane had a 30-point lead at quarter time, which I think you’ll agree is a handy start.

The Giants big problem was they were getting smashed at the clearances. At quarter time, Adam Kingsley gently reminded his team, like an under-eight coach, that you needed to go and get the ball and not wait for it to come to you.

With this reminder, the Giants started to get some parity, but this alone wasn’t enough, to get back in the game, they needed the Lions to spectacularly stuff things up.

And enter stage left, Brisbane’s goal kicking.

They kicked 8.16 and for once, this wasn’t Joe Daniher’s fault.

Instead, it was a raft of players who kicked for goal like those people who have spun around a cricket bat as part of some godawful halftime entertainment at a Big Bash game.

They hit the post three times, putting the posts into GWS’ best players. On top of that, two shots went out on the full.

Still up by 15 in the last quarter, the Giants then came storming home. It’s beginning to feel a bit like 2019 for the Giants.

They are a real chance to get smashed in a Grand Final.

North Melbourne (97) v West Coast (102)

Like Houdini getting out of a strait jacket in a glass tank full of water, I’m still trying to figure out how North did this.

We all know the North Melbourne Football Club loves torturing some of the most loyal fans in the game, but this seemed sadistic even for them.

Up by 35 points at Blundstone Arena, in front of a big North Melbourne crowd of 6,619 people, it seemed a lock.

West Coast started to come at North in the third quarter but even then, it seemed in the 23rd minute of the fourth quarter, when Paul Curits booted a goal, things were sown up.

After all, the Kangaroos were up 96-77.

North fans however knew better. This had ‘heartbreaking loss’ written all over it.

The Eagles would kick the last four goals of the game, with Oscar Allen kicking the match-winning goal with just 18 seconds left.

It left the North fans wondering once again, why do I let them do this to me?

Fremantle (62) v Geelong (73)

Fremantle, despite having a decent season, don’t mind letting the close games slip.

Being a Dockers fans is certainly character-building. When you’re bad, which is often, you’re really bad, but when you’re good, you still lose games good teams should win.

They say, ‘Into each life some rain must fall’ but for Dockers fans, the saying is ‘Always expect damaging flooding.’

All this talk of teams rebuilding, just need to look at Geelong to see just how much nonsense it all is.

Standards, developing young players, evaluating talent accurately, knowing what you’re doing. These are more important than draft picks. Just look at how many top draft picks get wasted and you can see that is true.

Geelong sits in the top four, for what seems like the millionth year in a row.

It’s repetitive but they are like Law & Order, why change a formula when it’s working?

Essendon (86) v Gold Coast (87)

Arrested Development, Seinfeld, Cheers, Yes Minster, Blackadder, I Love Lucy, 30 Rock, Frontline, The Larry Sanders Show, Fawlty Towers and the Essendon Football Club.

We have been blessed over the years with some truly great sitcoms.

Perhaps the hardest thing for the writers of a sitcom is to remain consistent over the years.

To be honest, when James Hird left, I thought losing such a big cast member would hurt the show, but the writers at Essendon have found new areas to explore.

Bringing in Brad Scott has been a master stroke, as has making it appear the Bombers were finally turning the corner. Again.

But this week’s episode, losing to the Gold Coast Suns, who haven’t won away from home in over a year, with a kick by a defender after the siren, was arguably one of the best.

Mac Andrew, not only got involved in a melee but kicked four goals against Essendon, while the Bombers went 1.9 in the last quarter.

Sometimes you just have to recognise we have been blessed with one of the greatest sitcoms of all time.

Five stars.

Melbourne (51) v Port Adelaide (53)

Note since I sat in a movie theatre to watch Amy Heckerling’s 2000 film Loser, have I been so glad something is over.

Melbourne’s season has been an ongoing dumpster fire, even before it started, which is hard to do.

If you are looking for a guide for what you don’t want to happen in a season, this is your template.

Now to be fair, some of it was pure bad luck, while other events make you wonder what is going on.

There was Joel Smith being provisionally suspended for failing a drug test, Clayton Oliver’s myriad of stuff and Angus Brayshaw having to retire due to medical advice.

Then there was Christian Petracca’s injury, which saw Melbourne’s medical staff send him back on, Steven May breaking his ribs more than once and Max Gawn missing games injured.

Oh, and a forward line allergic to kicking goals.

Aside from that, it was a great year.

Losing to Port, in a boring defensive grind was a perfect way to allow Melbourne fans to put a line through September and tell the staff to prepare their summer estates to be ready early this year.

Now, if you’re standing, sit down. Port are second on the ladder and it’s round 22.

Looking forward to Port fans explaining how this is a terrible job by Ken Hinkley.

‘It’s not finals yet!’ I hear them yell. A fair point, but still, better than expected just a few weeks ago.

My new show Sport: The Unauthorised History is coming to Adelaide this Father’s Day, Sunday September 1. Ticket on sale now.

Sunday

Carlton (38) v Hawthorn (112)

The yin and yang of life. Carlton leaves the eight, but Hawthorn goes in.

The Blues have been rebuilding so long that there are many adults who can’t remember a time when they weren’t.

I remember. It was back last century, in a geological period known as ‘The Nineties.’

Back then, Carlton had the best team money could buy.

Since then, the Blues have been locked in a ferocious battle with Essendon to see which club can make more of a galah of themselves on a regular basis.

This year, things seemed to be going well for the Blues, only for a spectacular run of five losses in six weeks.

It has been a satisfying return to form.

The Blues are a bit like the British aristocracy, believing they deserve success because of things achieved a long time ago by other people.

Against Hawthorn, who are the club Carlton thinks they are, the Blues managed to be terrible both defensively and offensively.

Now we must get our head around Hawthorn being in the finals. It’s like we knocked an asteroid off course, only to learn it’s still going to hit us, only faster.

Richmond (51) v St Kilda (99)

It’s fair to say Richmond are not rebuilding on the run. They have come to a complete stop.

With Dustin Martin retiring, the wheels have certainly come off, and it’s hard to know when they will get new wheels.

There’s talk of them having a fire sale at the end of the year to get draft picks. I just hope they get Tobias Fünke to do the fire sale ad.

St Kilda have improved over the season, which is a nice change, they have even but up some respectable scores.

What would be exciting is for them to be good for an entire season. St Kilda are like a Melbourne winter. There’s the occasional day of sunshine that makes you feel good, but overall, it’s a cold, miserable experience.

Adelaide (111) v Western Bulldogs (72)

This would have been a handy win for the Bulldogs, but beating Adelaide is, well it’s not that hard but the Doggies couldn’t do it.

It was inaccuracy in front of goal that did it.

The Dogs kicked 9.18, with Sam Darcy kicking 1.5 and one out of bounds, which isn’t great.

Luke Beveridge said after the game, "Adelaide might have played the best game out of any team this weekend."

Which is sort of humble bragging, to make out that to have beaten you someone would have to have played incredibly well.

Plus, it’s not true, Hawthorn played the best game of the round, even if it was against Carlton.

My new show Sport: The Unauthorised History is coming to Adelaide this Father’s Day, Sunday September 1. Ticket on sale now.

With Adelaide booked in, I’ll be announcing other cities on my national tour in the next few weeks. If you want to be notified and aren’t on my mailing list, sign up here.

You can help support me in producing this ridiculous nonsense I churn out on a regular basis. Find out more here: https://titusoreily.com/support-titus

 

COMMENTS

Andronicus

Aug 12, 2024

{Instead, it was a raft of players who kicked for goal like those people who have spun around a cricket bat as part of some godawful halftime entertainment at a Big Bash game.}

True. Watching Brisbane kicking for goal reminded me of my mother-in-law trying to ride a unicycle.

Lilac Mist

Aug 12, 2024

ahh - you don't see enough wage theft gags...

Hylo

Aug 12, 2024

Bloated leg seems to have worked a treat. Some of your finest work Titus.

Take me home sweet Caroline

Aug 12, 2024

It slowly dawned on me whilst watching the umpires, who’ve never been better, paying insufficient intent against players that were actually trying to stop the ball from going out.

So that’s why they kept throwing millions of dollars at Gil and begging him to stay. That’s why they spent years and more millions on the world's longest and most farcical executive search.

They were doing everything they could to try and avoid putting Dillon in charge of the AFL. At least they tried. I suppose.

the g train

Aug 12, 2024

Very good, Titus. Glad to hear you're doing ok. Agree with everything you wrote.

Especially: "But this week’s episode, losing to the Gold Coast Suns, who haven’t won away from home in over a year, with a kick by a defender after the siren, was arguably one of the best." Essendon achieved something that is virtually impossible. And in such spectacular fashion. To be only down by 4 points at 3/4 time, against The Suns who were playing away--and then utterly utterly dominate the final quarter, and then to lose by a kick after the siren really takes some exceptional doing. The eerie thing is, we all knew that this impossibility was inevitable.

Ex-Tiger Jack Riewoldt after the Essendon game showed that he's really up with the very latest: "The Essendon edge is well and truly gone for that football club".

Rosscoe

Aug 12, 2024

Not sure which I enjoyed most here; the McRae slam, the Essendon sitcom or Carlton galah. Gotta go the slam though. Poor game by Sydney for three and a half quarters and fifteen minutes of life affirming joy that shut down all the Pies supporters who were getting smug and mouthy at the SCG. Priceless.

TAKING ELSTERNWICK BY STORM

Aug 12, 2024

But you left out 3RD ROCK FROM THE SUN and CURB YOUR ENTHUSIASM and FRASIER in your list:
Arrested Development, Seinfeld, Cheers, Yes Minster, Blackadder, I Love Lucy, 30 Rock, Frontline, The Larry Sanders Show, Fawlty Towers and the Essendon Football Club.

Essendon fan

Aug 12, 2024

Titus - quite a brilliant summation of Essendon. What a laugh - I'm feeling better.

Son of Plugger

Aug 12, 2024

A ripper KJR, Titus. Nothing new there.

"St Kilda are like a Melbourne winter. There’s the occasional day of sunshine that makes you feel good, but overall, it’s a cold, miserable experience." But these occasional good days for St Kilda merely creates false hope. Which leads to a colder and more miserable experience that no other fans can appreciate or even comprehend.

Ross Lyon was ecstatic at Port's performance against The Ds. "That's the type of footy we wanna play. Gritty, very low scoring, a defensive slog, infuriating for the fans. For Port to kick 7 goals in good conditions and still win--doesn't get better than that"

When then questioned about St Kilda's high scoring dominant victory over Richmond, Lyon said: "Yeah, look, it's not what I wanted, and this is not an excuse, but I'm a servant of the club--they told me they want the team to play in a style that was more conducive to high scoring entertaining footy. And you have to remember, we were playing the bottom side, so hopefully against a more competitive team--I'm sure our final score will be much lower."

Tim

Aug 12, 2024

Isn't it great that Craig McRae has now officially joined Collingwood FC as he finally displayed inherent sour grapes attitude of the club.

Hawkette

Aug 12, 2024

As usual - great work Titus.
My observation is that McRae is no longer Mr Happy-go-lucky… funny about that when your team loses.
Only 2 Melbourne based teams won on the weekend (unless you include Geelong).
Missed you last week, all the best.
LTx

Hawkeye

Aug 12, 2024

Titus, Please stop being "nice" about Hawthorn. As a Hawks supporter , I find it particularly disturbing!

Gyfox

Aug 12, 2024

A Collingwood player just a bronze Frequent Flyer............oh, the shame!

Mosis Syndes

Aug 12, 2024

Let's unpack a little dietary issue we have in common. To alert me to the fact a humble Viennetta is a killer could be a life saver. Saving lives via this slight, observational literary piece is a big feather in your cap, O'Reily!

There’s always money in the banana stand

Aug 12, 2024

Your reference to Dr Tobias Fünke and Arrested Development in one article is enough for me. Analysis and Therapist work at its best.

Harvey Danger

Aug 12, 2024

two AD references in one email.

Kudos.

Ian

Aug 12, 2024

I gave up on the Swans at three quarter time. They've bitten me before. I recall once in the 90s at the SCG they were 10 goals down at three quarter time. We left to go to the pub and the buggers got up. I still don't think a win against Collingwood, as fun as that is, heralds any great outcomes for the season. My money's on two quick final losses. I'm better off with low expectations, right? At least then I can be pleasantly surprised rather than bitterly disappointed.

John

Aug 12, 2024

Had you pegged for an AD fan!

Marcus

Aug 12, 2024

You are a very funny man, don't give up your day job.

saint peter

Aug 12, 2024

You are so right Titus. I am moving up to Southport to get away from the cold of Melbourne. I previously lived up in Brisbane for 18 months and missed 3 winters, It was heaven. As soon as the Saints wake up they will be up and join me. Southport Saints. And the Gold Coast are doing so well, they need a 3rd side up there.
Great work Titus the week off did your analyses the world of good.

Pope Paul VII

Aug 12, 2024

Spot on Titey re North. Everyone could see it coming but them.

Arky

Aug 12, 2024

Shame about last week. Made up for it extraordinarily quickly with the Calombaris gag though. As a North Melbourne fan/victim, I can bear Collingwood complaining about losing to a late missed 50m penalty with enormous fortitude.

Clarry’s underworld connection

Aug 12, 2024

Titus, your swollen ankle is gout. Lay off the foie gras and swap the Grange/Chateau Lafite Rothschild for a nice Napoleon brandy and you’ll be ok. Might I suggest the Château de Montifaud Heritage Louis Valet cognac as a nice palate cleanser and starting point for you (look in the family cellar.. there’s probably a case or two laying around).

Bring back Kev

Aug 12, 2024

So. The Bombers have returned to normal transmission. They are cruel bastards, aren't they?

Darren J Ray

Aug 12, 2024

Some great gags in here, Titus. I laughed so much at the Essendon stuff (at 1:50am), I reckon I've woken the neighbours. Calombaris, Melbourne's season ... love it. And two Arrested Development references in one sitting. Hope to catch you when you're in Brissie.

David Banks

Aug 12, 2024

Hope your leg feels better soon.

Macca RB

Aug 12, 2024

North Hobart are so popular in Tasmania that 200 000 Tasmanians have bought memberships for the rival, Tassie Unicorns, who like their namesake - don't exist.

Macca RB

Aug 12, 2024

ESSENDON COACH
I could imagine the scenes of ecstatic joy when the recruiting staff announced that Scotty would be joining Essendon as head coach.
Chris Scott, the multi finals @ premiership coach would be leaving Geelong to work at Essendon.
Imagine the dropped jaws, when multiple loosing coach - returning after his mega-successful term at North, walked into The Hanger and the club board realised that they had signed brad, not Chris.

Tony B

Aug 13, 2024

A sad Carlton supporter, given up all hope ..... again. Even lost the brown paper bag.

Arthur

Aug 13, 2024

Not quite sure your Dependent Edema will be rectified by flying privately…or are you referring to the “flying privately” the Dees get up to in the off season?

Wobbleguts

Aug 13, 2024

How good is Viennetta!

https://bandurart.Mystrikingly.com

Aug 15, 2024

Thanks for your marvelous posting! I genuinely enjoyed reading it,
yyou might be a great author. I will remember to bookmark your
blog and will eventually come back in the foreseeable future.
I want to encourage you to ultimately continue your grewat work, have a
nice morning! https://bandurart.Mystrikingly.com

Aundrea

Aug 19, 2024

It's actually a cool and useful piece of info. I am glad tht you shnared this helpful info with us.
Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing. https://66bb4c96e165c.site123.me

https://lvivforum.Pp.ua/

Sep 10, 2024

Heya i'm for thhe first time here. I came across this board
and I find It really useful & it helped me out much.
I hope to give something back and help others like you
aided me. https://lvivforum.pp.ua/