Aug 26, 2024

AFL

The Monday Knee Jerk Reaction: Round Twenty Four

20 Comments

Footy is a passion, not some cold hearted, spread sheet dominated rational exercise.

On a Monday, you want irrational reaction. You want emotion to trump reason.

What you really want is idiotic hysteria.

You've come to the right place.

Friday

Melbourne (57) v Daicos Brothers (103)

Even God was bored with this game, sending lighting to express his displeasure.

Unfortunately, the AFL are a godless bunch, and they made sure a pointless game resumed for a delayed pointless ending.

Both these teams can point to injuries, but with their lists, it’s a disgrace they aren’t in the eight and they’ll be more soul-searching going on than when you suffer a horrendous hangover.

The Pies will wonder if the league has figured them out, while the Dees will spend it defending a culture that has so obviously gone so awry that they could be a commercial television network.

Melbourne brought a real ‘NBA All-Star Game’ intensity to this, and the Daicos brothers did not, stuffing the stats sheet like American tourists at a buffet.

When it finally finished, Razor Ray received what appeared to be a guard of honour from both teams, but it may have been they were just making sure he left. 

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

Saturday

Hawthorn (170) v North Melbourne (46)

To give you some sense of just how bad North were defensively, this game was played in a light drizzle, and still, the Hawks poured on 170 points.

These two sides were meant to be at a similar stage not that long ago. The fact Hawthorn will play finals, and North didn’t even turn up for this shows you how much enthusiasm changes things.

When things aren’t going well, supporters just want to see effort, and North just don’t bring that.

This may have been a pointless game for the Kangaroos, but given they only won three games this year, that’s been the case for months.

A winning culture is built by, wait for it, trying to win.

Even in games that don’t ‘mean’ anything.

Its why tanking is a terrible thing for a club.

Like most things, true wisdom comes from Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade, such as when Garth says to a young Indy, "You lost today kid, but that doesn't mean you have to like it."

There’s a sense at North, told they are always building for the future and not this season, that they’ve come to not mind losing as much as they should.

Hawthorn on the other hand hates losing. It is never acceptable.

You can be unsociable, you can do over-the-top celebrations, the only thing you can’t do is lose.

Geelong (168) v West Coast (75)

Are there any finalists more under the radar than Geelong?

They are the stealth bomber of the finals, making them the only Bomber in the finals.

The Cats finished third, have a heap of finals experience, and go into a finals series so wide open, they have to like their chances.

Geelong also got this late training run against the Eagles, who didn’t even try to hide how much they didn’t care about this game 

With the Cats up by 100 points at halftime, the Eagles were a little better in the second half but it would have been hard to match the disaster that was the first half.

Jeremey Cameron booted nine, helped by the fact the Eagles defence seemed genuinely scared of him. Wherever he was, they were not.

The Eagles season can be characterised as a little better than the one before, but beating historic lows is not something to be too proud of.

Richmond (66) v Gold Coast (94)

A game was played to meet contractual obligations.

The Suns won, and Richmond secured the wooden spoon, then Tigers fans said 

Goodbye to Dustin Martin, Dylan Grimes and Marlion Pickett.

That’s about it really. 

Brisbane (87) v Essendon (67)

Brisbane challenged Essendon to a night of seeing who could make the worst decisions and skill errors, and while it was close, the Bombers were always going to win that contest.

Bombers fans have every right to be furious with their team. They’ve had decades of being told things are going to be different, only for the same outcome again and again.

Be patient they are told, then they watch the old enemy, Hawthorn, shoot past them like a Ferrari overtaking a tricycle.

They don’t over-promise and underdeliver, they promise not much and manage to limbo under that each year.

Brisbane didn’t exactly impress in this one. They seemed at times to be new to the sport.

Luckily for them, they face Carlton in week one of the finals, the equivalent of discovering you’ve got a substitute teacher on the day you were meant to have a big test.

It means that with this game, then the bye, then Carlton, it will be about a month until they play an AFL side.  

Not always an ideal preparation for finals.

Sydney (121) Adelaide (90)

The Crows headed up to Sydney on Saturday to help anoint the Swans minor premiers.

The first quarter saw the Crows match it with the Swans, but after that they put the secateurs back in the shed.

Adelaide had a season-best forgotten and have not exactly left their supporters feeling positive about next season.

Not even accusing Port fans of having no teeth has gone well. That used to be a sure thing.

Luckily for Crows fans, they have complete faith the club knows what it’s doing.

The Swans have now locked in the double chance, and there’s every chance they’ll need it.

This season has not been predictable. Now some would say that’s the way the AFL designed it, with their focus on equalisation, but normally, when the AFL tries to achieve something, they produce the opposite.

So who knows what is going on? Still, at their best, the Swans are a cut above everyone else, it’s just their worst is pretty bad.

My new show Sport: The Unauthorised History is coming to Adelaide this Father’s Day, Sunday September 1. Ticket on sale now.

Sunday

Western Bulldogs (98) v Greater Western Sydney (61)

Probably no one else has observed this before, Ballarat is windy.

Why is it so windy? I don’t know, probably something to do with its location, geography and prevailing weather patterns. I know as much about the weather as I do about the footy.

What I do know is the Bulldogs are going to be trouble in September. Not bad given Luke Beveridge had lost the players just a few months ago, and that was true, it was in the media.

Here they were against another finalist, and they handled it.

The only negative was Liam Jones facing a nervous wait for the Match Review Officer.

The Giants it must be said did have a few outs. The way the results fell, they will now have to travel to Sydney in the first week of the finals.

Getting from Western Sydney to Sydney is a trip on par with Perth to Melbourne and slightly more dangerous.

Carlton (74) v St Kilda (76)

Can we just begin by saying whoever threw the water bottle at the umpire is an idiot. For starters, Marvel has more CCTV than a high-security prison.

They’ll find out who it was. The punishment is simple. All the umpires get to throw water bottles at the person. Let he who is without sin cast the first water bottle.

It was comical in the end. With the Blues up and almost no time yet, you just knew the Saints would get a goal.

Despite us all knowing this, it didn’t make it any less funny.

Now some say you shouldn’t find enjoyment from other people’s misery, but whoever says that isn’t a sport fan.

That’s a huge part of being a sports fan.

Social media was abuzz with people barracking for the Saints, desperate to see the Blues miss finals.

The mood spread to the umpires who also became keen to see Carlton miss out. It even spread to some of the Blues players, who missed easy opportunities.

In the end, if Carlton fans had souls, they would have been destroyed. Again.

Now they had to wait and see if Fremantle, a team known for also torturing their fans, could do them a solid and losing in heartbreaking fashion.

Spoiler alert, they could!

Fremantle (67) v Port Adelaide (87)

It wouldn’t take a few hours, but depending on how you frame it, Fremantle either did Carlton fans a favour or prolonged their misery.

Needing to win to play finals, Fremantle did not.

What was worse was they fumbled their way to this loss while Matthew Pavlich had to commentate.

Pav was working hard to be the ultimate professional, praising the Power in the final quarter, but it did feel a bit like a hostage saying they were being treated well in a proof of life video.

As the Dockers, who were in striking distance, fumbled the ball repeatedly, they finally broke him.

“They just keep fumbling,” said Pev a man in pain.

It’s cruel stuff this game and Pav represented every Dockers fan who must wonder how over the last few months they managed to play themselves out of the finals.

Over the last few months, it honestly felt harder for them to do that than to make the finals.

Pav reflected that when the pressure was on this year the Dockers were found wanting. You could hear the emotion in his voice.  He was both mad and disappointed.

As for the Power, they were again impressive. As we all predicted at the start of the year, they finished second on the ladder.

Can they win the premiership? Of course, every team in the finals except Carlton has a chance!

Phew. I go through the whole column without saying ‘put the cue in the rack.’

My new show Sport: The Unauthorised History is coming to Adelaide this Father’s Day, Sunday September 1. Ticket on sale now.

With Adelaide booked in, I’ll be announcing other cities on my national tour in the next few weeks. If you want to be notified and aren’t on my mailing list, sign up here.

You can help support me in producing this ridiculous nonsense I churn out on a regular basis. Find out more here: https://titusoreily.com/support-titus

 

COMMENTS

Gyfox

Aug 26, 2024

Titus - is this a game of, Find The Typos? I found 2: MCG & Fev!!

John McClure

Aug 26, 2024

The analysis of Melb/Coll was definitely one of your best. "stuffing the stats sheet like American tourists at a buffet" and "they were just making sure he left" are gold plated classics.

As a crows member for 25 years - "Luckily for Crows fans, they have complete faith the club knows what it’s doing" had me in stitches.

Good solution for the water bottle thrower - not as silly as it sounds.

Keep up the great work.

Ruth Robinson

Aug 26, 2024

“Unfortunately the AFL are a godless bunch….” well, maybe not totally godless, they do worship at the altar of the betting industry. Oh and the altar of the broadcast networks.

Wal

Aug 26, 2024

Your best of the year, in a very good TO year is to be found in the last game of the regular season. The 'proof of life' video reference. Golden gold.
Go Hawks

Tony B

Aug 26, 2024

Umpires 32 and 12 at the Carlton game should have been wearing St Kilda jumpers. I have never seen any umpiring so one sided. The other umps were ok, normal and the goal umpire didn't deserve a bottle to the head. The crowd was ready to riot early in the second quarter chanting 'bullshit, bullshit, bullshit' about what they were watching. You are right about the AFL and umpires Titus, actors and fools.

Stephen Boland

Aug 26, 2024

This is too true:

"Now some say you shouldn’t find enjoyment from other people’s misery, but whoever says that isn’t a sport fan.

That’s a huge part of being a sports fan." - Eagles fan thinking about Freo and Collingwood.

TheGStation

Aug 26, 2024

One of the untold stories of the weekend, was that at 3/4 time the umpires in the Carlton / SK game were overheard whispering (wonderful technology these new telescopic amplifiers of sound):
"Oops, aren't we supposed to help get Carlton over the line"
"What do you mean?, what's that?!? I thought we were supposed to get SK over the line!"
"No, no, ...our instructions were clearly 'Carlton'; it's the crowds I think. More money for the AFL elite and perhaps a better chance of a pay-rise for us"
"Yes..yes...you're right. I remember now, Good heavens, we'll be sacked!! Boys, let's right the ship. Now."

In the last quarter, Carlton got 8 frees in a row - It wasn't just Carlton's plans who were foiled when Missy Higgins snuck that last goal in

the g train

Aug 26, 2024

O Titus--possibly your greatest work yet.

The Melbourne vs Collingwood summary was perhaps the finest summary of anything ever written. But Collingwood paid the hefty price of having lost 3 games after round 2. It's hard to recover from there.
.
"Now some would say that’s the way the AFL designed it". It's amazing that even before round O, the AFL had it's plan perfectly in place. The plan is fixed, but the path to the plan is dynamic. It's like when google maps told me at 4:17, in the middle of a traffic jam, I would arrive home at 4:53. About 50 m from home, the time just clicked over to 4:52. I was ready to mock google maps, but then unexpectedly a car reversed from the driveway. I had to stop and when I reached home, it was 4:53, just as google maps "predicted"". The AFL works in exactly the same way.

Mosis Syndes

Aug 26, 2024

Let's round up the sheep, O'Reily. We can give you a 1 year extension; Pev has picked out the odd keyboard fumble. Scrub up that part of your game and a 3 year deal will be tabled. You can bet your red and blue cravat on it!!

Hui…

Aug 26, 2024

Gyfox, I also think lighting was meant to be Lightning. I suspect too many Red Wines for Titus?

TAKING ELSTERNWICK BY STORM

Aug 26, 2024

Titus, allow me to speak with absolute frankness.

You've had a bulldog-shaped blind spot for most of season 2024 and displayed a tendency to give WB short shrift.

With the league's second-highest percentage and
the second-highest PF (Points For) statistic and
the absolute lowest PA (Points Against) statistic, it's time you gave WB longer shrift.

In other news... No, there's no other news.

Running Dog

Aug 26, 2024

I reckon THEGSTATION is onto something. I'm sure there was a message in that bottle, a desperate SOS- Save Our Season. Hands up all those at AFLHQ who would have preferred a St Kilda win?
V
V
V
V
V
V
V
And that, folks, is the sound of a chirping cricket.

Son of Plugger

Aug 26, 2024

Titus--an absolute beauty this week.

You're obviously well versed in Zen Buddhism, Titus. Your harsh Kaons in today's KJR were sublime. So many. "If Carlton fans had souls, they would have been destroyed. Again." "Needing to win to play finals, Fremantle did not". "AFL are a godless bunch, and they made sure a pointless game resumed for a delayed pointless ending". Etc, etc, etc....
As footy supporters, we've all had our fair share of suffering, misery and false hope. With a few fleeting moments of Joy. But your words, Titus, in today's KJR remind me closely of Zen Master Seung Sahn: “Human life has no meaning, no reason and no choice". And master Baizhang: “You can't cut the chains of cause and effect.” With your words today, Titus--footy fans will have a great awakening.

"It was comical in the end. With the Blues up and almost no time left, yet, you just knew the Saints would get a goal."
Despite us all knowing this, it didn’t make it any less funny". That's pure Zen. The Divine Comedy.

Fat Side

Aug 26, 2024

re: the Tiges - if you plan to fail and succeed at failing, have you failed or succeeded? Another one for the Zen master to ponder.

WA Bogan

Aug 26, 2024

I propose that the entire Dockers team get honoured in the next Australia Day awards for services to the non Dockers population in WA. They bring us so much joy.

Doug

Aug 26, 2024

For those who say umpirdecisions don't affect results, I give you evidence that umpiring decisions can affect whole seasons.
Recall the umpire who awarded a free kick to Freo because Daicos Jr didn't leave the ball on the ground, which led to the goal that drew the game. Had he used his common sense instead of inserting his ego into the game, Collingwood would have been in the 8, Carlton would have missed out, and Freo wouldn't have been on contention.Thats what 2 points for a Magpie-Docker draw did to the finals.

DavidG

Aug 26, 2024

Not that long ago Titus was claiming that the east coast media was biased for ignoring Freo, who were second at the time. Turns out the media are smarter than they are sometimes given credit for. Not that much smarter though, because they keep believing that one day Essendon will win a final.

DougNeedsZen

Aug 26, 2024

Dougie if i can help one Collingwood supporter it will help me believe i have some zen like qualities such as compassion and understanding even though i am overridden with schadenfreude at your insightful post.
Zen suggests that anger often stems from attachment—whether to our desires, opinions, or ego. By practicing non-attachment, we can reduce the hold that anger has over us. Letting go allows us to respond to situations with calmness and clarity rather than reacting in anger.
In the other words of Paul McCartney: let it be, let it be…….
Enjoy the offseason……

bloke from the outer

Aug 29, 2024

'Now some say you shouldn’t find enjoyment from other people’s misery, but whoever says that isn’t a sport fan.'

As a Tigers fan this year has been abysmal... but I have gotten a lot of joy watching the wobbles lose.

bloke from the outer

Aug 29, 2024

You have to laugh at Collingwood and Carlton supporters whining about umpiring. 5th and 7th in differential in 2024 - then again that is a bad year for Collingwood when they are 3rd over a 60 year period. Sooks.