Footy is a passion, not some cold hearted, spread sheet dominated rational exercise.
On a Monday, you want irrational reaction. You want emotion to trump reason.
What you really want is idiotic hysteria.
You've come to the right place.
Thursday
St Kilda (67) v Hawthorn (119)
I have a mate (suspend disbelief for a moment) who never does anything on a school night.
St Kilda reminded me of him on Thursday night.
They came out of the gates like someone at the end of a nine-hour bender leaving a pub.
As the Hawks piled on the goals, the Saints didn’t boot a single one in the first half. They haven’t done that since 1987.
They were historically bad. They equalled their lowest halftime score since 1957.
The only thing stopping Hawthorn in the first half was the umpires.
Nick Watson kicked a goal after the siren and the crowd erupted.
The umpires then decided they hadn’t had enough of the limelight and ruled he ran off the line.
It was ridiculous.
Friday
Carlton (88) v Geelong (84)
A few weeks ago, Carlton played football with the enthusiasm of a person going to the electric chair.
Now they play with the excitement of a bus full of women off on a winery tour.
For Michael Voss, this must be like watching your ex marry the rebound guy.
The statue of Josh Fraser is already being built outside Visy Park.
It’s astounding how he has turned them around. Everyone else made coaching Carlton look like driving a car with no petrol in it.
The Cats would be furious after this game.
Dealing with the loss to Carlton was one thing; having the ARC fail to not work again was another.
Ollie Dempsey’s non-goal wasn’t reviewed by the ARC.
That’s the wonderful thing about the ARC, it can do a bad job when it reviews things, and it can do a terrible job when it doesn’t review something.
Technology was meant to improve things, but more often than not, it makes things worse.
The internet and social media have ruined society, stop-start technology in cars is annoying and the ARC somehow makes umpiring even more infuriating.
If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.
Saturday
Sydney (170) v Richmond (56)
Charlie Curnow always seems to shine when the stakes are lowest, and they couldn’t be any lower for the Swans in this one, facing a Richmond side that could barely find enough warm bodies.
This was not really a game, more a light training run for the Swans, as the Richmond VFL team struggled to meet the pace, intensity and skills of one of the best sides in the competition.
It was like watching a greyhound race a Chihuahua, except less entertaining.
The Swans can’t really take much out of this, while the Tigers have one key thing to work on, stop injuring all their players.
Brisbane (78) v Fremantle (103)
The Dockers have now won eleven in a row and are destroying teams with a casual ease that is scary.
They are going so well, they’ve turned Patrick Voss into a star.
That’s the Patrick Voss who was cut by Essendon and just kicked four goals against the reigning premier. Zach Merret should try to get to Freo.
I’ve been so impressed by them I’ve started paying attention into their team.
Did you know Nat Fyfe has retired?
The Lions however, look to be in trouble. They’ve left their homework to the last minute before and still delivered an A+ but they’re way off currently.
The way back is simple to say but hard to do, their stars need to play better.
Chris Fagan just needs to channel Homer Simpson as a boss.
“Are you guys working?”
“Yes, sir, Mr. Simpson.”
“Could you, um, work any harder than this?”
“Sure thing, boss.”
Western Bulldogs (97) v Collingwood (93)
The Bulldogs, on the ropes with injuries for most of the year, have put together two strong weeks to turn their season around.
It was the stars who came to the fore in this one.
Jordan De Goey and Nick Daicos for the Pies and Ed Richards and Marcus Bontempelli took the game to a whole new level.
One thing that’s great to have in any football side is great football players.
A little secret I’ve picked up from my years studying the game is you really can’t have too many great players.
One is fine, two is good but don’t stop there, try and get more.
Some teams don’t learn that. They have gone for zero great players. Weird, huh?
It’s easy to get them. All you need to do is identify them when they’re young, have the right picks in a ridiculously compromised draft, develop them over years and hope they don’t demand a trade to Hawthorn or Geelong when they become a restricted free agent.
Nothing could be simpler.
If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.
Sunday
Melbourne (70) v Greater Western Sydney (119)
The Dees have now lost their last four games in Alice Springs, not ideal when you’re selling home games. It’s selling wins for money.
And just quietly, the Dees have a pretty good home ground. It’s a little oval called the Melbourne Cricket Ground, and it suits them really well.
Not that Alice Springs was the only reason they lost. The Giants have a guy called Clayton Oliver. The Dees could use a player like him.
The Dees had two major issues. One, they couldn’t score when they went forward, which triggered some suppressed trauma, and secondly, they couldn’t stop the Giants scoring.
While the Demons entered their forward half with the coordination of a group of kids always picked last for any sporting team, the Giants were precise.
When they went into their forward line, they kicked, accurately, to a teammate, often on their own, rather than kicking it directly to an opponent of to a three-on-one.
Revolutionary stuff.
West Coast (85) v Essendon (55)
Getting James Hird back is possibly the worst idea since someone said, ‘Should we take serve rabbit terrine to a room full of Collingwood fans?’
Somehow, they’ve created a situation that has scared away every premiership coach looking for a job.
Essendon are a bin fire, in a dumpster fire, and that dumpster is in the reactor room of Chornobyl, and things look like they are somehow getting worse.
They didn’t even get the post-coach sacking bounce.
This seemed to be the ceremonial passing of the baton for the biggest basket case in the AFL from the Eagles to the Bombers.
The win was especially impressive for the Eagles given this was being played in a wind tunnel.
Conditions made it tough for the Eagles, but the Bombers skills seemed the same as normal.
Byes: Adelaide, Gold Coast, North Melbourne, Port Adelaide
You can help support me in producing this ridiculous nonsense I churn out on a regular basis. Find out more here: https://titusoreily.com/support-titus
COMMENTS
RD
Jun 01, 2026
Attention Ollie Dempsey and Geelong - Ben Keays and Adelaide say "Hello"
Janeo
Jun 01, 2026
A friend, far wittier than I, suggested at the weekend that perhaps James Hird should be the president of the Liberal Party and Toby Abbott coach the Bombers........
Bailey Bayley
Jun 01, 2026
Now Essendon can embark on another rebuilding phase.
Yippee.
Lilac Mist
Jun 01, 2026
Well done Titus - Pat ‘The Prancing Pony’ Voss is a cult hero at Freo and everyone else HATES him. A Hayden Ballantyne for our time. Next week’s assignment is to notice just how freaking good the Murphy Reid : shai Bolton combo is coming out of centre stoppages!
Hobart Jack
Jun 01, 2026
I think Jimmy Hird is entitled to do a Kamahl and ask “why is everybody so unkind?” - and then release his own version of “The Impossible Dream”.
Verna Wellington
Jun 01, 2026
No mate we do not need a player called Clayton Oliver!!
the g train
Jun 01, 2026
Agree with everything you wrote this week, Titus. Although I thought you were a bit off with the St Kilda vibe.
This was the perfect result for a St Kilda fan. At half time the miserable empty feeling at half time was worn as a familiar and strangely comforting cloak. In the second half, they were competitive. The St Kilda fans left the game with the quick fix of false hope--"if we can play like that for a whole game, we will be ok." And Ross Lyon after the game gave a positive spin: "Look, the first half wasn't great--but to end up with 9 goals is close to where we wanna be. We're working hard on restricting the opposition to scoring less than that. We'll get there"
Young Jumping
Jun 01, 2026
Clayton Oliver. "The Dees could use a player like him". As well as getting sliced up by him, imagine if Melbourne was burning a million pus a year of their own money paying him, plus burning their salary cap space not GWS's, only to have him doing that to them. Implausible I know but, as I say, just imagine.
Son of Plugger
Jun 01, 2026
Really good, Titus. Harsh at times, but always fair.
And no, no one knew Nat Fyfe had retired. That's what I love about Titus's Knee Jerk Reaction--you learn stuff that no one else could ever possibly know.
"It was ridiculous." What WAS ridiculous, Titus-- in the 3rd quarter of the Melb vs GWS game, the Giants had 7 F50 entries for 5 goals, The Ds had 18 F50 entries for 2 goals. That's gotta be the true historic event for this round. Even allowing for Quantum Mechanics, Uncertainty Principles and random probability theory, how is this even possible?
Actually, perhaps even more ridiculous--the current and clear 2026 Premiership favourite may not even make the finals. Carlton.
Anthony Hastings
Jun 01, 2026
The opening for Carlton literally had me laughing on the floor; the rest of the entire post had me just laughing!
For mine the best yet. Bravo
Simon Coombes
Jun 01, 2026
As an observer from the UK, I watched Bombers v West Coast in 2023 at Marvel and one of the Bombers fans said ‘This will be one of the worst games of footie you’ll ever see (even though it was an exciting 74-73 win for the Bombers). So not much has changed I see.
I think you need a relegation in this league to keep it exciting! You can’t just be rubbish and then look to next season. Where’s the fun in that? As a football fan on the UK it keeps some interest even if you are rubbish. Keep up the great reviews ;)
Simon.
Cancun
Jun 01, 2026
Simon above, I think Essendon deserve to be relegated immediately. Establishing an AFL second division can come later.
Paul Minogue
Jun 01, 2026
Watching the Melbourne/Giants game yesterday I kept asking myself the same question, "Why is Simon Goodwin coaching Melbourne again?"
Floreat Pica
Jun 01, 2026
In your capacity as a fearless investigative observer of our great game, I await your probe into Josh Fraser's shameless destruction of the wonderful coaching legacy of the previous ex collingwood identity to coach Carlton.
saint peter
Jun 01, 2026
I agree with you 100% or more if it is possible, on the Stop-Start technology of cars. I think is just a fad we are going through so it will take until next year before they wake up.
I did not know that Nat Fyfe had retired. Typical AFL & the Melbourne Media. Because it didn't happen in Melbourne, they forgot about it. Thought no-one was interested. I guess they had to leave space for preparing us for Scott Pendelbury's 433rd game.
Ross is so positive it is scary. We haven't seen angry Ross as yet. I guess that's because he wants to keep his job and not allow er I don't know, Corey Enright to take over.
UpTheGuts
Jun 01, 2026
I'm not convinced that you can blame the ARC for the Cats loss to the Blues. Given the fact that the Geelong defence failed to notice the one person on the ground, who has a number of priors for winning tight games of his own boot, hurtling towards the goal square at the games death. Talk about time to go to Specsavers. Everyone at the G, my mate in Kansas Missouri and Mr Magoo saw him coming. The Geelong defenders heads were on a swivel like Trumpy at a porn convention and couldn't see the obvious about to occur. The only Geelong player to catch a glimpse was the key forward line player, who has the defensive skills of an average Auskicker. At least Jezza threw an arm in the general direction of the perpetrator. So, I think we can let the ARC and Mr Roden (a fine goal umpire) off on this occasion. Well played Mr Cripps. 3 Votes.
The G Station
Jun 01, 2026
Titus,
Amazing the breaking news you provide, like Fyfe for example. Might've gone unchecked for months - but you missed this one:
Brett Ratten holds a higher win percentage at St Kilda than Ross Lyon has achieved during his second stint.
Ross's winning percentage is decreasing every season.
Given that Corey Enright will leave the Saints, there is a big push to bring back the Ratt!! (Like Hird at Essendon)