Footy is a passion, not some cold hearted, spread sheet dominated rational exercise.
On a Monday, you want irrational reaction. You want emotion to trump reason.
What you really want is idiotic hysteria.
You've come to the right place.
Thursday
Essendon (72) v Port Adelaide (60)
If you watch the second quarter of this, you may be entitled to compensation for pain and suffering.
After one goal, the next didn’t come for 23 minutes.
Those 23 minutes felt like 23 years, as both sides seemed incapable of anything resembling an athletic feat.
Kicks went directly to opponents, marks were dropped, tackles missed, and decision-making was of the ‘you guys guard the bee’ type.
After that, the game did improve somewhat, but the Bombers kicking for goal didn’t, as they seemed to be going out of their way to lose this one.
The problem was, as much as Essendon tried to lose, Port were just more determined to lose.
It’s going to be a long season for Port fans. I wouldn’t put it past them to sack Hinkley then Carr.
Friday
Carlton (75) v Western Bulldogs (83)
In life, you can be happy, or you can be a Carlton supporter.
How the Blues haven’t been reported to the Human Rights Commission for what they’ve done to their fans, I’ll never know.
If this sort of psychological warfare was being perpetrated on any other group, there would be outrage, but it’s happening to Blues supporters so were all fine with it.
Again, they performed the old bait and switch. They appeared to have come good, only to then fall apart.
The Dogs, despite a slow start, were comfortable in the knowledge they were playing Carlton.
They slowly worked their way into the game, and it got so close, that everyone wondered in what way the Blues would lose.
Turns out they let Aaron Naughton off the chain, and the Doggies are now in the eight.
They just have to hang in there for the next five months.
If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.
Saturday
Melbourne (62) v Gold Coast (120)
As a lifelong Dees fan, I’ve seen some bad footy in my time, and this was right up there.
The Demons looked like they had never seen a football before, let alone touched one.
It was like there were two different footballs out there. One was bone dry, the other covered in soap, as the Dees dropped marks and fumbled the ball all day.
It turns out that sitting around a campfire singing Kumbaya all preseason is not the best way to prepare for a football season.
Matt Rowell was superb, as were all the Suns midfielders. They sliced Melbourne apart with their strength and speed.
Gold Coast already have two away wins and a percentage of 230.6.
Sure, they’ve only played Melbourne and West Coast, but could this be the year people on the Gold Coast discover they have an AFL team?
As for Demons fans, this is starting to feel a lot like the 1970s, the 1980s, the 1990s, the 2000s, and the 2010s.
St Kilda (135) v Richmond (53)
St Kilda had a job to do, and they did it. As a fan, that’s what you ask for but often don’t get.
The Tigers haven’t won at Marvel Stadium since Damien Hardwick said he hated the stadium. They’ve played eleven games there since then.
They weren’t bad in the first half, but a 14-goals-to-two second half making this a hard watch for anyone not a Saints supporter.
The main talking point was Rhyan Mansell pushing Liam O'Connell into a pack, resulting in O'Connell going off.
There were a few of these in the preseason so the AFL will be keen to send a message with the three-match suspension they’ve offered.
It is peak AFL to suspend Mansell, given the umpires on the day rewarded a free kick to Tom Lynch for the incident.
Hawthorn (76) v Greater Western Sydney (64)
You couldn’t have a humbler, success-starved group of people than Hawks fans, and that’s why we’re all just thrilled they are back on top of the ladder.
When the last period of Hawks domination ended, we survivors stumbled out into the light, like bunker dwellers emerging after the apocalypse. The air was so sweet, the sun warmed our faces.
We thought it would last forever. We were fools.
All too quickly we are back here, and while I know some people are suffering around the globe more than me, it doesn’t feel like it.
If you wonder why the AFL demands a roof for Tasmania’s new stadium, you just had to see the wind at this game.
Every goal in the first-half were scored with the wind. Players were holding on the goal posts not to get blown away.
And yes, I’m aware Launceston and Hobart are different places, but when I looked on a map, they are just centimetres apart from each other.
Brisbane (70) v Geelong (61)
It was déjà vu all over again for the Cats as the Lions came from behind to gun them down.
Last time, it was the preliminary final when the Cats led by 25 points. This time they led by 32 points.
Brisbane certainly likes to start slowly this season. They’ve trailed in every game this season, only to come back and win them all.
It’s almost like they looked at last year’s slow start to the season and thought, ‘let’s do that in games too’.
That might be a risky strategy though as the season progresses.
After Round One, people were proclaiming Geelong the Premiership favourite, now the Cats are 1-2.
The good news, is they have Melbourne this week, so will be 2-2 after four games.
Sunday
Adelaide (114) v North Melbourne (78)
The Crows have scored over 100 points in all their games this season, and while someone cynical would say they’ve only played Essendon, St Kilda and North, you’ll find no such cynicism in my columns.
North were in touch right until the third quarter, but the Crows were, to use a technical term, better.
North learnt the hard way that you can’t play Melbourne every week.
They just lacked the polish and scoring options the Crows had.
It’s their 12th loss in a row at Adelaide Oval, which is not the most surprising stat given how they’ve played in recent years.
But the improvement is there. They seem to have talented players AND a game plan. They used to have neither.
As for the Crows, they face the Suns next week, which will surely tell us if they are the real deal.
Right now though, they look to have a rare thing indeed, a working forward line.
West Coast (68) v Fremantle (106)
The Dockers needed a win, and luckily for them, they got to face the Eagles.
It was close early, mainly because the Dockers seemed to match the Eagles skill level, but soon they’d tidied that up and were away.
It was the undermanned Dockers midfield that made the difference, with Caleb Serong winning a record-equalling fourth Glendinning-Allan Medal with 35 disposals.
Serong could certainly set the record for most Glendinning-Allan Medals, given he is still young, and his career lines up with this Eagles side.
The Eagles are still a fair bit off AFL standard.
Once again, Harley Reid had a game to forget, and late in the game shoved Caleb Serong to the ground in a completely unnecessary moment.
Trying to bully a guy who’s just shredded your team for four quarters is an interesting move.
I’m not sure what going on with Reid but he seems as happy as I was that time I went to a wedding with vegan catering.
Byes: Collingwood, Sydney
You can help support me in producing this ridiculous nonsense I churn out on a regular basis. Find out more here: https://titusoreily.com/support-titus
COMMENTS
Don Francisco's Sister
Mar 31, 2025
Somebody needs to do an
undercover investigation at St Kilda.
Normally the Saints avoid kicking goals like American billionaires avoid paying taxes, but some kind of transmogrification is now going on. How and why?
Terry
Mar 31, 2025
As I mentioned to you at Marvel after the North loss Titus, can you please please jump on the "sack Goodwin" bandwagon. Surely this has to be the year!
the g train
Mar 31, 2025
Excellent summary of all games, Titus. Agreed with everything you wrote.
However: "In life, you can be happy, or you can be a Carlton supporter." Shouldn't it be "or you can be a Carlton OR a Saints supporter"? To dismiss a lifetime of suffering and misery of a Saints supporter is cruel, Titus. There are many middle aged Saint supporters, and many heading towards senior citizenship, who have never experienced ANY happiness in life. None.
Titus--Ross Lyon loved the Essendon victory. He said: "It was scrappy, defensive, terrible to watch, and they kicked under 10 goals AND won. That's the way we wanna win. Today against Richmond--our first half was ok, but in the 2nd half--we ran in 3s and 4s and we had loose men everywhere. It was shocking. Hopefully when we play better teams than Richmond we can shut ourselves down better. And Max King coming back soon will definitely help clog up our forward 50 and reduce our scoring".
Fat Side
Mar 31, 2025
I'm not sure why Harley Reid stays at West Coast playing for a not quite AFL standard team, when he could come to Richmond and play on the MCG every other week for a not quite AFL standard team.
Khne Souness
Mar 31, 2025
Worthy of note - Isaiah very chuffed to receive Uncle Eddie's recycled shorts in time for his debut. They work!
Son of Plugger
Mar 31, 2025
Titus--Really good KJR. Irrational idiotic reaction trumps analytical reason. Again.
Ya just gotta really feel for Carlton. They're 0 from 3--and it's impossible to win a flag from there. As Titus reminded us last week. My brother's Carlton mate responded: "But Brisbane last year won from 0/3, so they proved it was possible". I didn't have the patience to explain why even though Brisbane did it last year, it's still utterly impossible. I thought it just wasn't possible that he would understand it.
"The Crows have scored over 100 points in all their games this season". Also, Titus--Adelaide has won all 12 quarters this season. Assuming that each quarter is a 50-50 contest, the probability of this is 0.00024. If they win the first quarter against GC, it would be an all time AFL record of 13 consecutive winning quarters--which has a 0.00012 probability. (Which is 0.00012 above the probability of Carlton winning the 2025 flag). Adelaide have played an improved, enhanced, faster, stronger, superior and optimized style this season. Or using a technical term--they've played better this season.
Fairwestuff
Mar 31, 2025
False hope!! after last week effort at the Gabba the Weagles played a competitive brand of football against last seasons Premiers but against the dreaded cross town opposition could only muster a first 15 minutes before Serong and the rest of the Dorkers midfield shredded the defence - one step forward two back I suppose Starting to resemble permanent cellar dwellers Oh for good times 92,94,06,18
A. Moron
Mar 31, 2025
Just here to read the comments of middle aged men pretending to be Titus, or hoping to impress Titus with their writing. Not disappointed. 4 stars.
Omnivore
Mar 31, 2025
Vegan wedding receptions are not funny. Endured one years ago. Tragedy plus time does not always equal comedy.
Vicki Tonkin
Mar 31, 2025
I married a lifelong Blues supporter and after watching him suffer alone for many years I finally took my marriage vows seriously and joined him in supporting them. Now we can truly suffer together in an unbreakable bond.
Joel Biden
Mar 31, 2025
I went to a booze free wedding once. Forgotten but never forgiven
John TURNELL
Mar 31, 2025
Go my Swans. Beat the Bye this weekend. (I know, I know: an Oldie but a Goodie).
Milhouse
Mar 31, 2025
The "Brisbane won the flag after starting 0-3" line should give sides hope. Melbourne is 0-3, but when Max Gawn says Gold Coast "broke our spirit", you know the times they are a-changing.
Bluesman
Mar 31, 2025
Now I know we're shit, G Train comparing us with Saints supporters for misery.
But probably fair.
Hey, we're 32 years into a 3 year re-build. Go easy.
Paul Young
Mar 31, 2025
North Melbourne were in the game until Adelaide’s top draft pick from last year, Syd Draper booted his first AFL goal. The goal triggered his signature song to blare across the Adelaide Oval, Frankie Valli’s 1967 hit - “Can’t Take My Eyes Off You.” This confused & mesmerised the Kangas, a 19yo kid with a 58 year old song, how is it so? For the rest of the game they couldn’t take their eyes off the Crows and watched them and thought - “you’re too good to be true.”
waverley heartbreak
Mar 31, 2025
we ran in 3s and 4s and we had loose men everywhere. I see what you did there Guru Bob.
Edward
Mar 31, 2025
As a Dees supporter, as I watched the match, all I could hear in my head was the voice of Jeff Goldblum's character (Dr. Malcolm) from "Jurassic Park" saying something to the effect "Now, eventually you DO plan on playing footy at your footy match, right? Hello?!"
"Ugly" is an understatement...
Pupper Mum
Apr 01, 2025
Highlight of my week so far. Lots of snort out loud moments.
The g train
Apr 01, 2025
@Waverley Heartbreak
Great to see Guru Bob is still alive in the hearts and minds of men. The Guru wrote: (the match) reminded me of the words the Commander of the British Garrison spoke after the retreat from Kabul in 1842: the opposition were running in twos and threes and there were loose men everywhere.
So yes, superficially, there appears to be some similarities. :)
I miss Guru Bob.