Jun 29, 2026

AFL

The Monday Knee Jerk Reaction: Round Sixteen

18 Comments

Footy is a passion, not some cold hearted, spread sheet dominated rational exercise. 

On a Monday, you want irrational reaction. You want emotion to trump reason.

What you really want is idiotic hysteria.

You've come to the right place.

Thursday

Brisbane (126) v Sydney (83)

Welcome to a truly horrible round of football, and this was one of the better games.

Brisbane have been only OK all year, but anyone who has paid some attention to footy in the past few years knows they often look poor early on, only to then blow everyone out of the water.

It’s almost like Chris Fagan is more interested in the end of the season than the beginning. What a weirdo.

The Lions exposed the Swans game, showing it’s hard to do little handballs to each other if you’re being relentlessly smashed by your opponents.

Brisbane’s biggest opponent seemed to be the umpires, who again made a howler after a siren.

This time Logan Morris had a goal he kicked wiped out after the umpire ruled that he didn’t return to his original line.

I don’t blame the umpires for this. 

The AFL have overcomplicated the game to the point that there are so many invisible lines, subjective decisions and magic fairyland rules, that it’s impossible to umpire.

Turns out adding more umpires and the AFL Review Centre makes the game worse, not better. I’m shocked!

With the World Cup on, this week’s Sports Bizarre Podcast looks at the first-ever World Cup, a hot mess of a tournament.

Friday

Hawthorn (96) v Greater Western Sydney (82)

A somewhat wild game, with the Hawks getting up to a 43-point lead in the third quarter, only for the Giants to come surging back.

The Hawks managed to hold on, but like a drunken man on one of those rodeo mechanical bulls at a bar in North Queensland. It was effective but not convincing.

Injuries played a huge role with the Giants losing both Brent Daniels and Max Gruzewski within minutes of each other.

Hawthorn had their own problem, with Nick Watson sitting out the second half due to hamstring tightness.

I believe ‘hamstring tightness’ fits above ‘hamstring awareness, but below ‘hamstring tear’.

I should add, I’m not a doctor, so that could be wrong, but I’ve heard numerous AFL commentators use those terms, and I think all of them are doctors.

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

Saturday

Carlton (117) v West Coast (64)

Who knew there was such joy in not being coached by Michael Voss?

The Blues players played for Voss like a bunch of children who had just been asked to get off their iPads and empty the dishwasher.

Under Fraser, they play like they’ve all been told everyone’s off to Timezone for unlimited free games.

And yes, Timezone still exists. I was dragged there for several children’s birthdays recently, and it is the loudest place on Earth.

There I learnt I’m old. I used to spend hours in arcades, but now I last a few minutes before I have to go find a café and have a coffee and a piece of cake.

Carlton have now won six in a row and 12th in the ladder. Suddenly, they could make the wildcard round, and the Blues making the finals is wild.

West Coast’s strategic flaw was they kicked the ball directly to Carlton’s defenders rather than their own forwards.

You’d think that would be something you could adjust on the fly, but no, that never seemed to occur to the Eagles players or their coaching staff.

Collingwood (106) v Richmond (72)

The real hero in this one is whoever managed to pull together a highlights package on the AFL website, because it was slim pickings.

Six goals to one in the second quarter saw the Pies break the game open, and then they just held the Tigers at bay.

The Pies were certainly helped by the fact that the Tigers don’t really tackle, and their skills are painful to watch.

Collingwood’s skill wasn’t that much better at times, as they butchered opportunities up forward.

Still, I kept watching, as the alternative was chatting to my family, and they were dead against that.

Port Adelaide (97) v Adelaide (71)

Once again, the Showdown shows ladder position isn’t relevant.

The Crows have been on fire, while the Power have been below average.

That all changed thanks to Zak Butters.

Against the Crows, he delivered 37 disposals, 13 clearances, nine score involvements and six intercepts.

He even trapped Izak Rankine’s leg in a tackle, forcing Rankine off, returning later with his knee strapped and limiting him to 12 touches.

Port Adelaide are lucky to have a player like Zak Butters.

He’s the sort of player you can build a team around for years.

With him on board, things just seems brighter, and you know you’ve got one of those extremely rare players who are irreplaceable.

No wonder Power fans are excited about the future. 

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

Sunday

North Melbourne (79) v Essendon (65)

I feel if you’re not a Bombers supporter, you’re in a win-win situation at the moment.

Somehow it seems the Essendon Football Club have positioned themselves between having either James Hird or Dean Solomon coach them next year.

I’m excited by both those candidates. I mean, not if it was for my team, but for Essendon, I say go for it.

While Josh Fraser’s impact at Carlton has been remarkable, Solomon’s has seemed to have little or no impact whatsoever.

Granted, it’s a team that seems borderline uncoachable, and a senior group of players who seem to actively dislike playing football.

Essendon keep saying they want to get a ‘real Essendon person’. Surely, given their history this century, they should be doing the opposite?

It seems ‘real Essendon people’ got them in this position. Surely doubling down ignores reality.

Oh, North Melbourne won this game.

Fremantle (80) v Gold Coast (29)

The Gold Coast Suns are like Ferrari’s first-ever electric car, the Luce.

No one was ever asking for it to exist, but the people in charge decided to spend 100 of millions of dollars developing it anyway, and the end result is an unimpressive mess that no one is interested in.

Against Fremantle, the Suns were up against a real Ferrari. A disciplined, fast and powerful team.

Gold Coast came out of the blocks slowly and stayed there.

They scored a measly three goals for the entire game and seemed like they were taking inspiration from the World Cup.

They’ve now lost five straight games and would not play finals if the season ended today, even if the AFL now hands out finals berths like they’re participation prizes.

Fremantle are the opposite, winning 14 straight and sitting eight points clear on top.

What an awful place to be for Dockers fans. They’ve never had things go this well. They’re not built to handle it.

Byes: Western Bulldogs, Geelong, St Kilda, Melbourne

You can help support me in producing this ridiculous nonsense I churn out on a regular basis. Find out more here: https://titusoreily.com/support-titus

 

COMMENTS

Stan

Jun 29, 2026

As a fellow Dee, I support your Essendon theory. After all, the last bloke that took them to glory was that born and bred lifetime Bomber Kevin Sheedy. (Consults almanac:
“ On the field, Sheedy played for Richmond in the Victorian Football League during the 1960s and 1970s, captaining the side in 1978 and winning three premierships. He then coached Essendon .…”

Across the Face

Jun 29, 2026

Yes, the logic being that only real Essendon people can clean up the mess that real Essendon people have made.

Hobart Jack

Jun 29, 2026

Titus, I feel the game is at the crossroads, on the precipice staring into the abyss, caught between a rock and a hard place and needs to take the bull by the horns and go for broke moving forward.
The decision must be made and it’s an obvious one - reduce team size to 6 a side and have 36 umpires on the field. That’s 3 umpies for every “contest” - what could they possibly miss, make a wrong decision nor god forbid, overrule the ARC on then?

Hobart Jack

By the way, with Cape Verde doing so well in the World Cup and considering it has a population equal to Australia’s smallest state - Tassie, of course - moves are underway down here to form a soccer team and build a stadium for it. A sure winner!

Orson Carte

Jun 29, 2026

Unfortunately us Power supporters see the light at the of the tunnel but it's a V/Line train coming.

Tigertragic

Jun 29, 2026

Another grim outing for the tigers - the much vaunted Richmond rebuild increasingly looks as principled and effective as the Victorian Government’s Big Build

Cancun

Jun 29, 2026

Whatever glorious past Essendon might have, when twenty or so of your current squad weren't even born the last time your club won a final, there's not a whole lot of club memory to draw on, is there, so it makes me laugh that they still think it's SO important to have "a real Essendon person" as their next coach.

Pablo

Jun 29, 2026

As a Freo supporter, you are absolutely right Titus. I'm not built for this, and I'm just waiting for everything to crap itself.

Blue Juice

Jun 29, 2026

As a Blues supporter for over 70 years I feel very much like Pablo. After 6 straight wins I know that a very large turd is on the way to the fan and I dread the day it hits! The only time I've seen them win a trophy was a pre-season NAB Cup against Brisbane in 2007 from which they went on to get the wooden spoon for the real season. And let's not mention tanking for fear of cursing the rest of the Blues season. For me a stress-free weekend is when the Blues have a bye.

the g train

Jun 29, 2026

I tend to mostly agree with almost everything Titus says as a rule, and this week is no exception.

Especially "I don’t blame the umpires for this." Of all the blokes running around during an AFL game, the umpires make the least mistakes. And it's much harder to umpire footy than to play it.

But then: "The AFL have overcomplicated the game to the point that there are so many invisible lines," The world is literally governed by invisible lines. So I blame the world, not the AFL.

SWANNIE

Jun 29, 2026

You never praise the Swans when they win and always bag them when they lose. A typical pissant AFL person. You can shove your Melbournian game you know where. In fact, AFL should just go back to Melbourne for your game to die. I’ve gone to the soccer.

Confused

Jun 29, 2026

Have you really Swannie?? After all you called it soccer not football.

son of plugger

Jun 29, 2026

Terrific stuff, Titus. Considering how poor the round was. But glad you showed true compassion to GWS over their injury woes.

But you should be a Dr, Titus. If I were a chancellor at a prestigious Australian university (eg Western Sydney University), I'd award you an honourary PhD for " Pioneering the Sociological Framework of Having Unwavering Faith in How Bad Other People Are".

We're getting towards the pointy end of the season. So how can it be that North Melbourne are above the raging premiership favourites (Carlton--because we know Freo will falter just at the perfect time)? It simply makes no sense,

The Purple Heart

Jun 29, 2026

You could tell Michael Voss was never a wordsmith when he was standing next to James Hird on that revered night. Hirdy could always walk the walk (after pig extract injections) and talk the talk (after accusations of introducing the afore mentioned to the whole club) but meanwhile Michael just bleated a few words and looked more like a sheep than a crook. I rest my case. Yikes!

The G Station

Jun 29, 2026

There's only two prestigious journalists in the industry who are hard enough, tough enough, and insightful enough to know that Ross Lyon is failing is his '2nd falling' at St Kilda. Kane Cornes and Titus O'Reilly

Lucky for Ross that SK had a bye this week, he gets a breather from the Titus O'Reily proverbial head-slam

saint peter

Jun 29, 2026

What a weekend. Did any play footy this weekend? As my team had a bye I thought it was a holiday for all of us. Oh well it is on next week so I better pay attention. I believe we are playing Essendon. I don't think we will lose cause Essendon are trying very hard to sure up last spot as they have Richmond down their necks.
I read titus's description of Essendon. It is so right. But hird will take reigns from Solomon when the season is over. Only Essendon people can fix Essendon's problems that Essendon people have made. So they will get in hird as he was the one that caused it all. He can fix this.

Stephen

Jun 29, 2026

As an Essendon supporter, I'm so glad the World Cup will cover most of the run-up to the Bombers not even coming close to a finals game. sigh.

FAT SIDE

Jun 29, 2026

@SWANNIE, if you don’t want our team any more, we’ll happily take it back. Signed, South Melbourne supporters.

Max

Jun 29, 2026

If you’re an AFL player, you’re part of the most tightly monitored group of adults in Australia. On match day, the numbers are stark: one umpire for every eight players. Three in the field, four on the boundary, two in the goals, watching fewer than fifty men in real time, from every angle, with replay.

Now compare that with the rest of the country. Australia has just under 70,000 sworn police officers for a population of over 26.7 million. That’s one officer for every 382 people. Not 382 criminals, 382 men, women, children, pensioners, tourists, and politicians alike.

The contrast? AFL players are policed roughly 50 times more intensely than the general population.

And yet, they still manage to bugger it up

Leave a comment

We promise to never share your email with anyone else.