Apr 07, 2025

AFL

The Monday Knee Jerk Reaction: Round Four

27 Comments

Footy is a passion, not some cold hearted, spread sheet dominated rational exercise. 

On a Monday, you want irrational reaction. You want emotion to trump reason.

What you really want is idiotic hysteria.

You've come to the right place.

Thursday

Collingwood (63) v Carlton (46)

Two big teams, in prime time and in front of 82,000 fans at the MCG! What’s not to like?

Well, firstly, the football.

Carlton’s woes are so well known now they’re barely worth repeating.

They could be a million points up at half time and Blues fans would still be nervous.

A Blues rebuild is like a Hollywood set, it looks real but look behind and there’s not a lot there.

And Collingwood wasn’t much better either, their biggest strategic advantage was that they were playing Carlton.

The bigger story was two blokes carrying loaded firearms into the ground.

You’d never see that happen at a Dees game. Mainly because there’s barely a crowd, and secondly, a musket is hard to hide.

There are so many questions about this. How did they get the guns through when the machine apparently flagged them?

Is it because the security look about as interested as I do when someone tells me about their feelings?

Then you have to wonder why two guys with illegal firearms decided attracting attention to themselves was a good idea.

Now the lines for the MCG are going to be so long that you’ll need to get there the day before just to get in.

Not like the AFL to overreact to just one incident.

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

Friday

Geelong (85) v Melbourne (46)

In the past two weeks, the Dees have played well below their level and been smashed.

This time they looked to play up to their level and got smashed.

Sure, they were in it to three-quarter time, but the way the rolled over late is perhaps even more worrying.

Geelong couldn’t believe their luck as Goodwin gave them loose men down back, the result saw the Cats take so many marks that even Geelong fans were suggesting helpfully that the Dees change tactics.

It would be fair to say the current brains trust at Melbourne have had long enough to figure out the forward line-midfield connection, yet here they are still kicking into the forward line like they’re blindfolded.

Geelong would be thrilled, they had the perfect game plan, ‘let’s wait for Melbourne to stuff up and then clean up.’

If I had anything resembling a social life, I’d give up on the footy this year, but instead, I’ll go every week and assume the position I’ve spent most of my life in.

Saturday

Gold Coast (91) v Adelaide (90)

Gee, those umpires really hate the Crows.

They’ve stopped them from playing finals, and they cost them this game.

Izak Rankine should have been paid a mark or a free kick in the dying stages, but the umpires were like ‘no man, we hate you and your whole club.’

At least, that’s what I believe happened.

Luckily for Crows fans, the AFL admitted the umpire got it wrong, so that means everything is ok.

Getting the AFL to admit it’s wrong is much rarer than a win, so it should be worth ten premiership points.

A sensible person would say ‘you can’t just focus on one call, there’s bad calls across the game, you just notice the ones late more. 

Well, I say to that person ‘I am not a sensible man at the best of times and when it comes to football I am completely unhinged, so good day to you.’

One thing I must admit is that the Suns are good.

Unless they fall apart in the second half of the season they will play finals, and I can’t remember them ever doing that.

Once again, I’m performing at Gather Round in ‘Lehmo and Titus’ Gather Round Extravaganza’. It sold out last year, so get your tickets here.

Richmond (90) v Brisbane (118)

I wish I had a dollar for every time Richmond are going to be referred to as ‘plucky’ this season.

Already, I would have at least seven dollars from this game alone.

‘Plucky’ is one of those words you get called when you’re not very good, but you try hard.

I’ve been called it a lot.

Tigers fans would be happy though, they’re young kids are looking promising, they weren’t blown away and the line to get in was only thirteen hours long.

Sam Lalor, Luke Trainor and Harry Armstrong look like the sort of players you can build a team around.

Brisbane are thrilled too. They won, and the MCG is no longer a terrifying place for them.

In fact, Will Ashcroft seems right at home there, with his third-quarter goal from the boundary an absolute highlight.

No wonder the Lions hope to field a team of eighteen Ashcrofts in the near future.

North Melbourne (52) v Sydney (117)

Things looked good for North when they beat Melbourne, but it turns out that’s not that hard to do.

While some were painting this as a disaster for North, you’re going to get games like this when you’ve got a young team.

It’s like raising kids, you tell them what to do and what not to do over and over, and they ignore you more often than not, then suddenly it clicks, and they no longer do silly things.

If they don’t learn, you trade them out, like when my family traded me for two cans of chickpeas and a packet of AAA batteries.

My former dad says it was the best trade he ever made.

The family I went to still regard it as the worst trade they’ve ever made.

Sydney will be thrilled to start getting some life back into their season.

Where North overused the ball and fumbled it a lot, the Swans didn’t. Not stuffing up is an underrated skill in this game.

Sunday

Greater Western Sydney (132) v West Coast (51)

The fall of West Coast is one of the greatest collapses in sport history, and amazingly it doesn’t seem to be over.

The Giants brushed the Eagles aside like a Giant brushing aside someone who isn’t a giant. See, I’m a wordsmith.

The Eagles defence had no answers to Jesse Hogan who kicked nine goals and could have had more.

At one stage he marked out in front and instead of kicking his tenth, he handballed to a teammate.

That is the sort of behaviour that gets you kicked out of the Forwards Union.

Unselfishness is not something you look forward in a key forward.

Still, nine goals is pretty good, even if it was against a WAFL side.

Port Adelaide (72) v St Kilda (89)

Ross Lyon has spent a lot of time this season talking about MAFS and the White Lotus, and this focus seems to be paying off for him.

St Kilda are not only winning, but they’re scoring too, which I put down to Ross watching more TV and relaxing a little.

Perhaps I can convince Simon Goodwin to watch some Real Housewives.

To win in Adelaide is always hard, even against Port, who seem keen to shoot themselves in the foot this season.

They looked like they were going to run over the top of the Saints at times, but each time they stuffed things up and the Saints, to their credit, took advantage. 

The good news is Ken Hinkley had a lot of goodwill built up amongst Port fans and it’s not like the eyes of the footy world are all turning to South Australia this week.

Once again, I’m performing at Gather Round in ‘Lehmo and Titus’ Gather Round Extravaganza’. It sold out last year, so get your tickets here.

Fremantle (97) v Western Bulldogs (81)

Any footy journalist (of which I’m not) who doesn’t spend most of their review of this game on Rory Lobb’s haircut, doesn’t know what they’re doing.

A few weeks ago, Lobb had a blue haircut, sort of an electric blue, that stood out but was fairly simple in its execution.

This week, however, Rory had his hair dyed white, then a red lobster stencilled on the back of his head.

Now to understand the lobster reference, you have to understand nicknames in sporting teams, as they are often fiendishly clever.

In this case, Rory’s surname is ‘Lobb’ and therefore he is sometimes called ‘the lobster.’

To be honest, I’ve stood in front of the Mona Lisa, I’ve seen the Sistine Chapel, and I was even once asked to stop climbing the statue of David, but I feel I haven’t lived until I see Lobb’s hair art in the flesh.

Byes: Hawthorn, Essendon

You can help support me in producing this ridiculous nonsense I churn out on a regular basis. Find out more here: https://titusoreily.com/support-titus

 

COMMENTS

PENGUIN

Apr 07, 2025

Laughing in the office. I think this week I will get plucky and buy me a musket. Lots of bush turkeys near my place.
There you go - I am wordsmithing!

Dempseys left boot

Apr 07, 2025

'Tigers fans would be happy though, they’re young kids are...' THEIR!!!

Other than above this was readable, you're a most plucky writer Mr O'Reily.

Someone

Apr 07, 2025

A couple of decades ago, someone suggested that there's a bit of an anti-Crows conspiracy going on at AFL House. And more recently, say twice in 2023, once in 2024, and again this weekend, that same someone has had that conspiracy confirmed by none other than the AFL themselves, who have repeatedly and publicly said that umpiring decisions/non-decisions will go against the Crows in the dying minute of the game if the Crows are within less than a goal and the ball is in their forward 50.

It's me, I'm someone.

Son of Plugger

Apr 07, 2025

Titus--pretty damn good. But not as good as The Umpires in their game against Adelaide. I was lucky enough to be able to interview the captain and the coach of the victorious side. I asked the captain of The Umpires what he thought of their win.

Captain: "Mate--it was perhaps even our finest victory ever. Adelaide refused to buckle, to their credit. But I was really proud, especially of those final two minutes when Adelaide threw everything at us--and we still somehow prevailed. In the years to come, people will look at that and wonder how we ever won. A great team effort by all three of us".

I quickly intervened: "There are 4 field umpires!"
Captain: "Really--how long has that been going on for? Alright, all 4 of us then".

Then Michael Jennings, Head Coach of The Umpires, added: "It was beautiful. At our very best, no team can beat us. We have a great rivalry going with Adelaide, and the record shows we consistently defeat them, usually by brutal plays right at the death. As Sun Tzu's Art of War says: in the battlefield, sometimes the best decision to make is no decision".

KNDole

Apr 07, 2025

Poor Adelaide Crows, they have been bleating about the umpires since Richmond beat them in the 2017 decider. My heart bleeds for them!

the g train

Apr 07, 2025

Agree with everything you wrote, Titus. Except this:

"St Kilda are not only winning, but they’re scoring too, which I put down to Ross watching more TV and relaxing a little." The actual reason is that there is this 40 year St Kilda member who emails the St Kilda president twice every week about his disdain for Ross Lyon and his defensive strategies. Eventually, all these emails were driving the president nuts. "Ross--I can't take these emails anymore....as President I have to read every friggin' email.....and reply to them. All of them. I've had a gutful. Just chuck out ya '10 or under' goal strategy!"

"Of course, Mr Bassat", says Ross. "I am but a humble loyal servant of the club and will do as you ask".

DW

Apr 07, 2025

I’m sure you meant to say “they’re young kids WHO are looking promising,”.
That’s what a real wordsmith would say.

Glermpt

Apr 07, 2025

With you on the pathetic nicknames Titus. Former Swan Ryan O’Keefe’s nickname was Pebs.
Why?

Ryan O’Keefe
= R.O’K
= rock
= pebble
= Pebs.

Straight up genius.

Khne Souness

Apr 07, 2025

No mention of BIG COX, Pal ... is that because neither of your families tolerate that sort of language?

Doug

Apr 07, 2025

Two blokes smuggle guns into the ground and the security response is instantly addressed. How come the AFL can act quickly on some issues but not on others? For example it was raining at the footy over the weekend, yet the AFL has not insisted the MCG put a rood over the stadium as it has with the proposed arena in Hobart. What gives, Mr Dillon?

TigesTragic

Apr 07, 2025

Not disappointed in the comments section. Grammar nazi second post. :-)

Zane Insane

Apr 07, 2025

Rory Lobb’s dad runs a cafe in Lancelin called
“The Lobbster Trap”, but that single fact doesn’t excuse anything his son has said or done as a footballer.

Fifth umpire

Apr 07, 2025

Would that be Rodney rood Doug?

Alan Montague

Apr 07, 2025

I am unsure whether your glass is half full or half empty or what you may have consumed to get the glass to the halfway mark, but keep doing it, as your words and insights are hilarious and a tonic (perhaps like the fluid once in your glass).

Kafka’s Ghost

Apr 07, 2025

”You get games like that with a young team”.
The rough thing for North is their team was more experienced than the one they played against.

Fat Side

Apr 07, 2025

Surely the AFL must realise that it's not the umpiring mistake at the end of the game that is the problem, but it is the first umpiring mistake of each game that sends the game into a whole new trajectory that makes all the other mistakes irrelevant. What they really need to do after each round is identify the first wrong decision in each match and ( probably using AI ) predict how the match would have proceeded if that mistake hadn't been made. They can then publish the corrected results for each match and arrange the ladder accordingly. You're welcome.

Ross

Apr 07, 2025

Adelaide fans, Crows and Power, were born to boo. The booing starts at the toss of the coin and continues for the entire game. And beyond. Occasionally the umps make a boo-boo and oh, the umbrage! The pain! I absolutely love it.

Robbie C

Apr 07, 2025

Really enjoyed reading today's hard hitting updates. The best part is you don't go on and on like a lot of the footy shows talking about superfluous dross. Boring hypotheticals like which club is MAYBE going to trade with who , contract extensions, who is worth a kazillion next year, and what gaffe a Ceo or boot studder said. Your superfluous dross is much better.
As a Saints supporter l can't work out if l love or hate Ross. When l listen to him l feel suicidal but we are winning so how should l think.?

The g train

Apr 07, 2025

@Robbie C “As a Saints supporter l can't work out if l love or hate Ross. When l listen to him l feel suicidal but we are winning so how should l think.?”

I hear ya, Robbie C.

@Fat side 100% agree. If we can use quantum computing, and master quantum gravity, not only can we re-adjust the results, we can use quantum retro-causality so that it feels like the results were never actually readjusted. You’re definitely on to something.

Delmorest

Apr 07, 2025

I do feel for the Adelaide players, officials and fans. Always being on the wrong end of the umpiring. Perhaps they could all go and have a cry into the 1997 Premiership Cup???

Don Francisco's Sister

Apr 07, 2025

Your family traded you for two cans of chickpeas and some AAA batteries, you say?

I bet every Christmas they made you take the family photo. That way you wouldn't be in it.

Ebenezer Diddly

Apr 07, 2025

North deserve to fail, and fail and fail again. Adam Goodes last game was the Swans semi-final loss to North Melbourne on September 19, 2015. He was booed relentlessly throughout the game by the North fans at the game.
For every boo he received, may North Melbourne finish another season in the bottom four.

Pablo

Apr 07, 2025

I think Titus that if GWS HAD played against a WAFL side it would have been a tougher game for them!

Gus

Apr 07, 2025

Fortunately, I have never been called 'plucky'. I'm not very good and never try.

Ross

Apr 09, 2025

Ebenezer: Re NM booing Goodes, I was there and I concur. They should suffer in hell.

boyarka-Inform.com

Apr 10, 2025

Heya i'm for the first time here. I came acrozs this board and I find It truly useful & it helped me out
a lot. I hopoe to gijve something back annd aid others like
you aided me. http://boyarka-Inform.com/

Mikea

Apr 11, 2025

Great review, Titus.
And some brilliant comments.
Just didn’t see that last one coming.
As the German soldier on Laugh In used to say from the bushes,
“Verrry interesting”

Leave a comment

We promise to never share your email with anyone else.