May 25, 2026

AFL

The Monday Knee Jerk Reaction: Round Eleven

18 Comments

Footy is a passion, not some cold hearted, spread sheet dominated rational exercise. 

On a Monday, you want irrational reaction. You want emotion to trump reason.

What you really want is idiotic hysteria.

You've come to the right place.

Thursday

Hawthorn (75) v Adelaide (66)

A tough week for Hawthorn with Tasmania breaking up with them after 25 years.

It’s a big blow, with the Hawks really enjoying sleeping over at Tasmania’s place, winning 61 of 87 games at York Park and now this game.

The Crows got off to a good start before Nick Watson did some of his wizarding stuff.

That all got paused when he got crunched in a marking contest, James Borlase's hip hitting the back of his head and then his head hit the turf.

It took three minutes to get him off, the ARC working as it always does, poorly.

The Crows big problem was that they couldn’t score when they had enough of it.

This was further hampered by Izak Rankine being limited with ‘calf concern.’

There’s nothing worse than a concerned calf, just ask any farmer.

The Hawks were just too good; if only they could keep Tasmania. 

This week’s Sports Bizarre Podcast is our series on Yankees owner George Steinbrenner, a man who appeared as a character in Seinfeld and fired everyone.

Friday

Richmond (74) v Essendon (56)

Dreamtime at the G saw two of the most injury-plagued teams in the history of the league go at it.

You’d think this would make them both keen to avoid further injuries, but they took to this with the intensity of a prison brawl. I saw a shiv out there at one point.

It’s lucky the MCG is close to several hospitals.

Matt Guelfi had a hamstring injury, Sam Durham suffered a concussion, Andy McGrath broke his jaw and Jye Caldwell played on but with an ankle injury.

To round things off, Archie May was taken to hospital after the game.

Richmond tried to keep up on the injury front; Jonty Faull was ruled out with concussion and Tom Lynch got an injured larynx.

Aside from injuries, both sides tried to outdo each other on the poor execution of skills.

Essendon’s 1.6 in the third term was the difference, however.

The Bombers now sit last on the ladder, with a solitary victory and a group of players who are either injured or have the morale of hostages.

Aside from Jacques Cousteau, no one has plumbed greater depths than Essendon.

Every time Bombers fans dare to dream that they’ve at least finally hit rock bottom, their club discovers an entirely new circle of hell.

Buying a Bombers membership is like funding your own unhappiness.

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

Fremantle (104) v St Kilda (74)

Not to alarm people but Fremantle are top of the ladder and have won 10 in a row consecutive for the first time ever.

We are through the looking glass people.

As well-known AFL analyst Kramer once pointed out, it’s about levels.

The Saints hung around all game, and were a point up in the fourth quarter, but that’s when the Dockers went up a level.

They poured on six goals, with Ross Lyon furious that once again the opposition were doing that ‘scoring thing’.

The loss took the Saints to 5-6, clinging to tenth spot, which used to not be a thing but the AFL are trying to make it one.

As for the Dockers, they may be scary.

Saturday

North Melbourne (111) v Gold Coast (105)

Gold Coast were up by 43 points in the second quarter, which would normally be a leading indicator of a win.

Especially considering North had just turned in an insanely poor performance against Adelaide.

This week, however, North decided not to give up, which proved a much better tactic.

Still, it was a long way back. At halftime they were still down 38 points, but luckily for them, the Suns were working through their Darwin hangover and were fading fast.

By three-quarter time, North were still 20 points down, but Gold Coast looked like they’d been on an all-night bender, not just Darwin, and they often do go together.

The Roos sensed this and upped their pressure, kicking six of the last seven goals as the Suns lay down and had a nap.

Geelong (107) v Sydney (80)

Two of the three competent AFL sides went at it on Saturday, with Geelong reminding everyone that they are a relentless winning machine that never takes a season off.

The Cats are so good at finding new talent that they have the luxury of resting Patrick Dangerfield for large periods of the game.

He still had more impact than many players out there for far longer.

Sydney mixed it with the Cats but soon they were 38 points down.

The problem with Geelong is everyone works hard. It’s deeply unfair.

Everyone knows almost no workplace does that.

When you look around most workplaces, it’s hard to see thirty per cent working.

That said, most workplaces don’t have Chris Scott breathing down their neck. 

If you want to ensure you get my columns every week, the best way is to sign up for the email.

Collingwood (92) v West Coast (82)

A special occasion with Scott Pendlebury breaking the record for most funds raised by a single player from merch in a single game.

It’s a record that may never be reached again.

And the Eagles came so close to spoiling the party.

This would have been especially embarrassing given the Pies have engineered this outcome for months.

West Coast obviously didn’t get the memo that they were meant to lie down and give the Pies an easy win.

Instead, they took it to them and the result was the Pies paying heavily for the win.

Jamie Elliott did his knee, Darcy Moore did his hamstring, Will Hayes dislocated his shoulder and Nick Daicos was sent for scans on his foot.

Apart from that it was a wonderful day for Pies fans.

Despite the close loss, for the first time in a long time, West Coast are doing a fair impression of an actual AFL side.

Port Adelaide (58) v Carlton (92)

Josh Fraser is in the conversation for Carlton’s greatest coach this century. It’s not much of a conversation, but that’s now two wins in a row.

The Blues are like a recently divorced fifty-year-old.

They’re enjoying their freedom, they’re having fun getting out there and are making lots of risky decisions

Sure, everyone knows reality will catch up with them again soon, but why not enjoy life until then?

Port looked so bad they made the Blues look dynamic.

They beat Geelong not that long ago, but have since rattled off four losses in a row.

This was by far the worst performance.

The Blues waltzed through the centre corridor with a casual ease that made you wonder if Port were paying any attention to the game at all.

Perhaps they need to sack their coach. Worked for Carlton.

Sunday

Greater Western Sydney (166) v Brisbane (88)

Lions fans may have sensed some trouble when the Giants, a team hardly known for high scoring this season, booted 14 goals in the third quarter.

That’s a lot.

The Giants scored 86 points in one quarter. The Giants rarely score 86 points in a game!

Up until that point, things were looking relatively even up until this point, making the third quarter massacre even more surprising.

It’s hard to describe Brisbane’s defensive pressure in the third quarter, mainly because there wasn’t any.

The Lions should request a priority pick.

Western Bulldogs (93) v Melbourne (90)

Ed Richards and Marcus Bontempelli tore Melbourne apart on Sunday, as the Dees seemed rather surprised the game had started, only getting into it late in the second quarter.

Despite Max Gawn hitting almost every ruck contest to advantage, it was the Bulldogs who took advantage time and again.

The Dees certainly worked their way back into the game, but were repeatedly their own worst enemy, fumbling the ball like it was an object they’d never seen before.

They also overcomplicated all their decision-making.

The final ten minutes saw plenty of heroics and mistakes from both sides

Jack Steele was streaming forward at one point, only for Rhylee West to chase him down.

The Dees got another chance, but Harvey Langford dropped a mark in the goal square.

The difference was the Dogs took their chances, the Dees didn’t.

You can help support me in producing this ridiculous nonsense I churn out on a regular basis. Find out more here: https://titusoreily.com/support-titus

 

COMMENTS

Hobart Jack

May 25, 2026

Titus I thought it was indicative of Pies fans and the Melbourne sporting fraternity’s generosity and appreciation of a fantastic occasion to turn up at the ‘G to celebrate rising super star Harley Reid’s 50th.
Apparently golden quokkas bearing number 9 are selling quickly - $2500 gets you one, cheap.

Maria Scott

May 25, 2026

What about commenting on the fact that Scott Pendlebury will donate a decent portion of the profits made from his record-breaking game to My Room, a charity for children's cancer.

Lilac Mist

May 25, 2026

Face it Titus,it’s time to actually learn a few Fremantle player names.

Crowy

May 25, 2026

Great observations again Titus. Apparently Dante's Inferno has nine levels in hell so Essendon can likley plunge further down if they really try.
A poor excuse but Port must have incurred that same Darwin hangover. Brutal heat and humidity will do that to you. How about the AFL send Collingood up there for a dose.

Bailey Bayley

May 25, 2026

......Buying a Bombers membership is like funding your own unhappiness......

True, that. Whenever the Bombers attempt a resurgence it's like when the Three Stooges find a sledgehammer, a saw and a crowbar. What could possibly go wrong?

Stephen

May 25, 2026

It is not just the Essendon players who have the "morale of hostages". Fans got there weeks ago and are now a mix of "meh", pure delusional, and planning their spring break early to avoid the rush.

Tony Hastings

May 25, 2026

“Like a recently divorced 50 year old” hahafa
That’s gold Jerry gold”

Running Dog

May 25, 2026

One name on Freo's list that everyone should know is Erasmus. One of his famous philosophical propositons was this: a player cannot 'drop the mark'. Only if the ball is caught does it become a mark. Therefore a player can only drop the ball. But Murphy, another one of Freo's resident philosophers, has refuted this, with an ironclad law of his own: if a player marks the ball and the umpire doesn't see it through the looking glass, then it's only the sound of one hand clapping. Free kick Hawthorn.

son of plugger

May 25, 2026

Pretty good, Titus--loved the steely indifference of: "The Dees got another chance, but Harvey Langford dropped a mark in the goal square." A rational sensible explanation for why The Dees lost.

GWS kicked 14 unanswered goals in the third quarter. The other 3 quarters were fairly even. This is a genuine once in a lifetime achievement. I calculated the probability of this. Assuming a Poisson probability analysis where the a priori average for the number of GWS goals per quarter is 3.5, we get the probability of 0.000000021. That's very close to the statistical probability of being killed by a meteorite. We witnessed a truly historical event. And T Greene was a big part of that.

Advahntage

May 25, 2026

Yeah, 14 goals in a quarter.

Does anyone else besides me think that would be a dull experience for the neutral spectator? I mean, just piling on an absurd number of goals with such ease and for so long?

It's a bit like in NBA games where both teams just trade basket after basket after basket after basket and there's really nothing to see unto the last minute when you find out who made the last basket and therefore won.

the g train

May 25, 2026

Agree with everything you wrote this week, Titus. Almost. "Buying a Bombers membership is like funding your own unhappiness." It should read "Buying a Bombers membership is funding your own unhappiness."

And loved your knee jerk reaction to GWS scoring 14 unanswered goals against Brisbane. Which was an understated reaction to a truly historical event.

In the first half of the first half of the second half, GWS kicked 9 unanswered goals. Footy old-timers were saying they had never seen a half like that. And they were literally right. In the second half of the first half of the second half, GWS did back off a bit and kicked only 5 unanswered goals. The other 6 halves of the game were evenly split. Which shows to win decisively you only need to decisively win 2 halves of the game.

John Allison

May 25, 2026

So GWS managed 14 goals in just one quarter. 14 goals - that's about how many goals Essendon have kicked in the last five decades.

ACROSS THE FACE

May 25, 2026

We are through the looking glass people.

You needed a comma between "glass" and "people" there, Titus.

The G Station

May 25, 2026

Lenny Hayes is Ross’ boss. Lenny by nature was raised in the high scoring era of pre- Ross Lyon, and Ross doesn’t know how to cope with Lenny having a different philosophy - Lenny ‘attack/defend’, Ross ‘defend/defend’ - an existential crisis is occurring right now at Morrabbin - one more loss and no-one’ll feel safe at a Ross Lyon post match press conference

saint peter

May 25, 2026

You can't write-off the Dockers until Sept comes around. Everyone knows that is their Achilles heel. Just tell em they have made the finals & they will crumble quicker than lay-down sally.

Norm The Dog

May 25, 2026

Living in Adelaide I watched Essendon trounce Melbourne in the Gather Round, so like Hawthorn being able to play matches in Tassie I was hoping the Bombers might apply to play all their home games at Adelaide Oval.

I began supporting the Bombers in 1957 at school in WA when another kid asked me who would win the VFL final, not having a clue but not wanting to appear so I said Essendon as dad was a good athlete with the Essendon Harriers Club in the 20's.

After watching the Tigers beat the Bombers and now 85 I hope the Bombers can extract the diget soon.
PS - Don't worry Titus Melbourne won in 57.

Fat Side

May 25, 2026

As health insurance is a form of reverse gambling ( you have be in need of medical care to “win” ) and the AFL seem to love the gambling industry, surely it’s time for one of the big health insurers to step up with some major sponsorship of the whole league. Each Monday they could run a highlight reel of the weekend’s player injuries to remind people why they need cover.

UpTheGuts

May 25, 2026

I’ve got a signed Scott Pendlebury jumper from circa 2011, it’s for sale on various gold digging sites. I’m at $84. Do I grab the cash quick sticks or hangout to reach the magic $100? What would Pendles do?

Leave a comment

We promise to never share your email with anyone else.