May 22, 2017

AFL

The Monday Knee Jerk Reaction: AFL Round Nine

35 Comments

Footy is a passion, not some cold hearted, spreadsheet dominated rational exercise.

On a Monday, you want an irrational reaction. You want emotion to trump reason.

What you really want is idiotic hysteria.

You’ve come to the right place.

Geelong (104) v Western Bulldogs (81)

The weekend got off to a bad start when I decided to have a shot every time the Channel Seven commentary team mentioned Geelong has a new stand.

I ended up consuming four bottles of whiskey, double my regular Friday night ration.

While the constant talk of the new stand was annoying, it wasn’t as annoying as the commentators complimenting each other on their commentating.

I guess the Channel Seven commentary box is the only place someone has ever said: “great call BT.” Even then, it’s by someone who is under contract to say that.

Geelong had apparently been saving up their tackles over the past few weeks for this game, as they laid 134 of them. It was like a partner who’s phoned in a few birthdays, so massively overcompensates on one.

The Cats players need to realise this is not a one off but the required regular effort.

They can’t do what some people do around the house, which is wash the dishes once, tell everyone about it and then coast for the next month.

The Bulldogs, on the other hand, are perfecting the ‘almost win’. Bulldogs fans have every right to be angry. I mean what has this team done for them lately?

St Kilda (68) v Sydney (118)

My tips are terrible this year, proving that I must know an awful lot about football.

Further proof of this, is that my nemesis, Janice in Accounts Receivables, is ahead of me and she thinks Dangerwood is where Ivan Milat committed his crimes.

St Kilda were meant to have arrived this season, but they didn’t even arrive on Saturday. They were so poor; I thought they were doing an impression of the West Coast Eagles.

The Saints seemed to be only interested in turning the ball over, targeting Swans players with a pinpoint accuracy that would have been impressive if they’d done it to teammates.

Sydney now seems like 2016 Sydney. They’ve remembered how to tackle, kick and score. Amazing what a few returning players will do for a side.

It’s such a weird season that the 3-6 Swans seem well placed to make the finals, especially as the teams above them keep inventing ways to lose.

Greater Western Sydney (78) v Richmond (75)

Richmond need to start funding counselling sessions for their fans. It would send them bankrupt, but you can’t do this to people without some form of compensation.

I hope all employers let Richmond supporters drink alcohol openly at work this week. It’s the right thing to do. They don’t even need a glass, just straight from the bottle.

Many people watched this game thinking ‘certainly Richmond couldn’t do this two weeks in a row’, but real Tigers fans knew that not only they could, but they would.

GWS were down by 25 points at three-quarter time, ideally placed really, and stormed home with 33 points to Richmond’s five in the last term.

Giants coach Leon Cameron said after the game that Richmond were the better side in the night, which only the Tigers could be and still lose.

The weirdest thing is, Richmond are the top Melbourne based side in the competition, sitting seventh and falling. No wonder the AFL are talking about a ‘wildcard weekend’.

Brisbane (60) v Adelaide (140)

Adelaide’s Hugh Greenwood used to play basketball. Don’t worry about remembering that fact; you’ll hear it a thousand times in the next year.

He did make a good debut though, although people forget to mention it was against the Lions, probably the only team with no chance of being Premiers in this crazy season.

With no real pressure, the Crows looked like the Crows of the early rounds again, exciting, high scoring and with Eddie Betts doing things that aren’t allowed under the laws of physics.

Brisbane looked terrible. They can pull together about ten minutes of competitive footy a game at this point. Losses like this don’t exactly help their quest to retain good players either.

There’s an easy fix for the Lions though, just merge them with the Suns. A merger worked for them in the past. In fact, just keep bolting teams onto them, like some sort of footy Voltron.

Give a team to Tasmania too, just because putting an AFL team where someone wants one would be a novelty these days.

Collingwood (90) v Hawthorn (72)

A Hawthorn loss usually feels like all the happiness in the universe crammed into one incredible moment. This one, however, was offset by a Collingwood win, which is all the bad feelings in the universe occurring all at once.

As a result, I felt nothing at the end of this, although that could be because I had just consumed several ‘illusion shakers’ due to their ingredients being the only thing I had left in the house, the remnants of a party held in the 90s.

A Collingwood loss seemed a sure thing early on, with the Hawks getting out to a 43-point lead early on.

Buckley though gathered the players together and pointed out that if he got sacked, so would a lot of the team.

That was enough to motivate the team and coupled with the fact Hawthorn are pretty ordinary, led to an impressive comeback.

It was classic Buckley, let the pressure build with a few losses, then pull off a win to keep things from getting so bad the Board are forced to do something about it.

He may not be a good coach, but he dodges bullets better than Neo.

Hawthorn’s issues run deep, and not just the fact that all their possessions belong to one player. Luke Hodge was also obvious a meal short in his Lite n Easy delivery this week, getting fired up in the game after receiving some rough treatment.

It’s understandable he got upset. You don’t see Hodge running around taking cheap shots at people.

Essendon (125) v West Coast (64)

Under dynamic ticketing, the AFL should cover the cost of any Eagles fan that came over from Perth for this.

It’s often said the Eagles shouldn’t bother coming over for games in Melbourne and it appears that advice is now being followed.

West Coast fans have every right to be furious at this performance. There was no effort whatsoever, just turning the TV on at home meant most Eagles fans exerted more effort than their players did.

There is an excuse for the Eagles.

This was the first AFL game to feature a female field umpire, Eleni Glouftsis. That presents an opportunity for West Coast, as the tradition goes in footy, don’t blame yourself when you can blame a woman.

Obviously, a female umpire is bad luck. Just like having a woman on your boat can attract sea monsters.

I do want to congratulate the footy media for not saying anything sexist about Eleni Glouftsis’ debut.

Let’s be honest, the odds of us getting through her first game without a comment about her appearance or the fact having a female umpire was ‘political correctness gone mad’ were low.

Still, it’s early days, and you just know someone won’t be able to restrain themselves much longer.

Essendon looked like the greatest side ever, but it’s hard to judge when your opponents look more like a group of people waiting at a bus stop.

The Bombers do have a lot of great young talent though, and their fans should be getting excited.

Joe Daniher has even started kicking straight, something previously though impossible by science.

Melbourne (90) v North Melbourne (104)

In a season that’s all over the shop, it’s comforting that some things never change, like North Melbourne’s stranglehold over Melbourne.

There’s no shame in losing to North Melbourne 16 times in a row, it could happen to anyone, except for the fact it hasn’t.

It means the last time Melbourne beat North Melbourne was in 2006. The Prime Minister back then was John Howard. We’ve had about thirty Prime Ministers since then.

There are eleven-year-old Melbourne fans who have never seen Melbourne beat the Kangaroos. Imagine being an eleven-year-old Demon fan? They didn’t even get to experience the 90s when Melbourne were slightly less awful.

There were a lot of complaints about the umpiring from Demons supporters, but the Demons don’t need the umpires help to lose games, seeing participating in some quarters is believed to be optional for many players.

The stark reality of this season is that few sides can put together four quarters. It’s why almost anyone can beat anyone, from any position.

Consistency is a foreign shore upon which no team has yet set foot on in 2017.

North played this game very well, they just waited for Melbourne to do their aggressive push-up defence and then counter attacked over the top with some of the easiest goals you’ll ever see.

That’s Melbourne’s game plan this year, it sometimes works exceptionally well like it did against the Crows but when it doesn’t it’s awful, and Goodwin seems to have not yet developed a plan B.

North wasn't perfect but they made a lot fewer mistakes than the Dees, and they matched them for physicality all day.

Anyway, they say it’s the seventeenth time that’s the charm.

Fremantle (86) v Carlton (51)

Carlton started off well and tried all day, but a couple of injuries and the fact they’re Carlton held them back.

Fremantle were meant to do most of the heavily lifting for footy comedy this year but have decided not to play along. Luckily, about five other teams have rushed in to fill the gap.

The Dockers have instead started winning with alarming regularity. They aren’t having the huge, flashy wins of some teams but they haven’t been getting belted recently either.

It’s classic Ross Lyon, and with the way the competition is going, the Dockers’ ‘Lose the Grand Final’ window may be open sooner rather than later.

And to think, they’re doing this without Zac Dawson. Amazing.

Bye: Gold Coast, Port Adelaide

You can help support me in producing this ridiculous nonsense I churn out on a regular basis. My aim is to keep as much of my stuff on this site and available to everyone and not behind paywalls. Find out more here: https://titusoreily.com/support-titus

COMMENTS

Johno

May 22, 2017

Too true about Zac Dawson ... teams he have taken an age to recover

Left the Hawks after 2008 .... they missed finals the following year and floundered about until 2012 without him

Left the Saints at the end of 2011 ... ha anyone seen St Kilda since?

And now after being benched by the Dockers ... well. If he goes at the end of the season it's most likely they'll get relocated to Tasmania!

Milo

May 22, 2017

Richmond is the top Victorian side in the comp? Sounds like Geelong has been given its marching orders... !

Pete

May 22, 2017

The weirdest thing is, Richmond are the top Victorian side in the competition, sitting seventh and falling. No wonder the AFL are talking about a ‘wildcard weekend’.

Geelong?

Polymick

May 22, 2017

Pure gold Titus if you keep this up I am going to cancel my sponsorship and use the money for extra incontinence pads.

Titanium

May 22, 2017

Geelong are not "Melbourne-based"

John Meckiff

May 22, 2017

I just checked my atlas and Geelong is definitely not in Victoria. They are in a world of their own, but close to Tasmania

Elias

May 22, 2017

He said top Melbourne side, and try as it might, I don't think Geelong is yet a suburb of Melbourne.

stevo

May 22, 2017

"Bulldogs fans have every right to be angry. I mean what has this team done for them lately?" Well, to be honest, not much......the umpires did it for them!

Nick

May 22, 2017

Titus, love your work, although, as a paid up subscriber, your one trick with regards to Hawthorn is getting really boring. Can't you find something funnier to say than 'I love it that the Hawks are getting beaten'? I want value for my hard earned cash! (although the quip about Tom Mitchell getting all the side's possessions was pretty good.) Think harder - even friends who support other clubs think you are getting a bit lay on that score. But hey, maybe you are just reflecting the cations of the Hawthorn leadership group...

Cameron'sFrecklyFaceScaresTheKiddies

May 22, 2017

Ross may never be a premiership coach, but wins points from me for shit-stirring the journos when they ask idiotic questions. Very few coaches are worth watching in their post-game interview/charade.

He'd also be man enough to tell Janice that she's an idiot.

There's probably a very lame joke to be made about the Demons coach's surname, but I'm not funny and I can't be stuffed thinking of one.

Panco Pete

May 22, 2017

You've outed yourself stevo. You're obviously that annoying Stevens bloke on Channel 7 who seems to think a free kick against Murphy on the wing half way through the last quarter cost the Bulldogs an automatic goal and an automatic win.

Faye

May 22, 2017

He dis say Melbourne based side, not Victorian.

Chris

May 22, 2017

Jokes about Hawthorn losing never got old...

Ian

May 22, 2017

Can we get a "Carey Career Comeback 2018" movement going? Anything would be better than having him in the commentary box for another season.

Sam

May 22, 2017

Dermott talked about enjoying.listening to Eleni breaking up a fight in the second quarter. Not necessarily sexist, but probably best kept to himself.

L23

May 22, 2017

He said Melbourne based

Joe

May 22, 2017

I was wondering if you were going to mention the endless references to High Greenwood and basketball, and you didn't disappoint.

Tony

May 22, 2017

is everyone now aware that Geelong is in fact not a suburb of Melbourne?

Luke

May 22, 2017

The relative lack of sexism during the bombers game was encouraging, but it didn't stop Lord Brereton saying "oh would you listen to that? I think I'd stop the biff if I had a women telling me instead of a bloke". Poor form.

Domitian

May 22, 2017

Nice John Oliver reference.

John Nicholls

May 22, 2017

Consistency is a foreign shore. I don't know where on Earth that is, but if it's where Carlton is going for the end of season trip, I'm in. Barassi always insisted on good away trips after the grand final.

Swampy

May 22, 2017

The moment you start to say "as a...." it's time to get off the internet and go do something else.

Emma B

May 22, 2017

I ❤️ the fact that you excluded Geelong from your list of Melbourne teams, Titus.

Swanette

May 22, 2017

Hows your liver then Titus?

Paul J

May 22, 2017

Dare I say the repeat jokes about about the hawks are ''too old, too slow and too bloody good"

Jona

May 22, 2017

As a Dockers fan and one who's well aware we're on our way to another guaranteed GF loss in 4 years' time, I have I agree with Cameron Freckly Face - kudos to Ross Lyon for 'calling out' shite journalists. And I hate the term 'calling out'. My favourite from yesterday was when he asked Dale Miller what a 'Litmus test' meant. Miller didn't seem too sure about the Chemistry of it all, rather he knew it was a good footy cliche, and was buggered if he had to think of another cliche to explain it with...

Randall

May 22, 2017

As one requires a helicopter to commute between melbourne and geelong it is difficult to argue a case that geelong is a suburb of melbourne

Mr. Barratt

May 22, 2017

Bronwyn Bishop agrees with you

Reuben

May 22, 2017

While I generally agree that Zac's as useless as tits on a bull - and I'm a Dockers tragic - he kicked a couple of goals in the reserves/WAFL this weekend! The end is nigh...

Nobby Cliche' Butcher

May 22, 2017

Don't listen to them Titus , I love Hawthorne jokes on repeat. Its like , flared jeans , safari suits , and the fro . Its only stale until it comes back into fashion , given Hawthorne list ,30 years should be plenty of time for them to be edgy again

Pat

May 22, 2017

Can a city be a suburb?

Andrew Deakin

May 23, 2017

Commentary slip of the round was "It's double déjà vu," during the final moments of the GWS/Richmond game. Should have been "It's double déjà vu all over again."

DJKL

May 23, 2017

Don't worry about the media seeming to avoid sexism, Titus, this moron has it covered:
https://thewest.com.au/news/wa/footy-chief-attacks-female-umpire-ng-b88483402z

ATTIC Nightclub Sunbury

May 23, 2017

"The Midori Illusion Shakers are on me" said the year 2003

Bill

May 24, 2017

Up to round 9 Geelong has played three home games in Melbourne one in Geelong and played two away games in Melbourne and three away games interstate. Its finals home games have been mainly played in Melbourne in recent years. Technically they are home based in Melbourne at this point of time because Titus references Richmond's position on the ladder up until round 9 you can only take into account home games to that point of time not into the remainder of the season. Geelong is Melbourne based as at round 9 the point in question. Technically Titus it could be argued that you are wrong in saying Richmond are currently the highest based Melbourne club if the definition of home based is where the side plays its home ground games.